Readit News logoReadit News
QRY commented on Writing with LLM is not a shame   reflexions.florianernotte... · Posted by u/flornt
Refreeze5224 · 8 days ago
If the tool does the task for you, then you didnt do the task. I don't keep my food cold, my refrigerator does. I just turned it on. This doesn't matter unless I am for some reason pretending I myself am keeping my food cold somehow, and then that becomes a lie.

When a tool blurs the line between who performed the task, and you take full credit despite being assisted, that is deceitful.

Spell checking helps us all pretend we're better spellers than we are, but we've decided as a society that correct spelling is more important than proving one's knowledge of spelling.

But if you're purportedly a writer, and you're using a tool that writes for you, then I will absolutely discount your writing ability. Maybe one day we will decide that the output is more important than the connection to the person who generated it, but to me, that day has not arrived.

QRY · 8 days ago
When does a woodworker cease to be one? When he uses a handsaw? A circular saw? A sawmill?

> When a tool blurs the line between who performed the task

Who saws the wood? He who operates the tool, or the tool performing its function? What is the value of agency in a business that, supposedly, sells product? Code authorship isn't like writing, is it? Should it be?

Or is the distinction not in the product, but in the practice? Is the difference in woodworking vs lumber processing?

Or is it about expectation? e.g. when we no longer expect a product to be made by hand due to strong automation in the industry, we prepend terms such as "hand-made" or "artisanal". Are we currently still in the expectation phase of "software is written by hand"?

I have no dog in this race, really. I like writing software, and I like exploring technology. But I'm very confused and have a lot of questions that I have trouble answering. Your comment resonated though, and I'm still curious about how to interpret it all.

QRY commented on Coding with LLMs in the summer of 2025 – an update   antirez.com/news/154... · Posted by u/antirez
simonw · a month ago
The models I can run locally aren't as good yet, and are way more expensive to operate.

Once it becomes economical to run a Claude 4 class model locally you'll see a lot more people doing that.

The closest you can get right now might be Kimi K2 on a pair of 512GB Mac Studios, at a cost of about $20,000.

QRY · a month ago
Have you considered the Framework Desktop setup they mentioned in their announcement blog post[0]? Just marketing fluff, or is there any merit to it?

> The top-end Ryzen AI Max+ 395 configuration with 128GB of memory starts at just $1999 USD. This is excellent for gaming, but it is a truly wild value proposition for AI workloads. Local AI inference has been heavily restricted to date by the limited memory capacity and high prices of consumer and workstation graphics cards. With Framework Desktop, you can run giant, capable models like Llama 3.3 70B Q6 at real-time conversational speed right on your desk. With USB4 and 5Gbit Ethernet networking, you can connect multiple systems or Mainboards to run even larger models like the full DeepSeek R1 671B.

I'm futsing around with setups, but adding up the specs would give 384GB of VRAM and 512GB total memory, at a cost of about $10,000-$12,000. This is all highly dubious napkin math, and I hope to see more experimentation in this space.

There's of course the moving target of cloud costs and performance, so analysing break-even time is even more precarious. So if this sort of setup would work, its cost-effectiveness is a mystery to me.

[0] https://frame.work/be/en/blog/introducing-the-framework-desk...

QRY commented on Hundred Rabbits – Low-tech living while sailing the world   100r.co/site/home.html... · Posted by u/0xCaponte
QRY · a month ago
Their work has molded a lot of my views on technology, such a breath of fresh air when I first found out about them! They really inspired me to look at my own work and ask how to make it more resilient, how to decrease dependencies.

From my experience, achieving provider independence boils down to: own your stack, work offline-first, test failure modes constantly.

Been trying to get a setup going with NixOS + local AI + custom CLI tools for development work, and I never would have thought to pursue this sort of thing if I hadn't found these people. Great stuff!

Oh and ORCA is a LOT of fun! Give it a shot if you're into sounddesign, or generative electronic music stuff: https://100r.co/site/orca.html

QRY commented on Mistral Releases Deep Research, Voice, Projects in Le Chat   mistral.ai/news/le-chat-d... · Posted by u/pember
Nezteb · a month ago
Depending on the definition of "nicely", FWIW I currently run Ollama sever [1] + Qwen Coder models [2] with decent success compared to the big hosted models. Granted, I don't utilize most "agentic" features and still mostly use chat-based interactions.

The server is basically just my Windows gaming PC, and the client is my editor on a macOS laptop.

Most of this effort is so that I can prepare for the arrival of that mythical second half of 2026!

[1] https://github.com/ollama/ollama/blob/main/docs/faq.md#how-d...

[2] https://huggingface.co/collections/Qwen/qwen25-coder-66eaa22...

QRY · a month ago
Thanks for sharing your setup! I'm also very interested in running AI locally. In which contexts are you experiencing decent success? eg debugging, boilerplate, or some other task?
QRY commented on Belgian CVD is deeply broken   devae.re/posts/belgian-cv... · Posted by u/piecrumpled
QRY · 2 months ago
Well then. I'm Belgian, and I was considering exploring security more professionally. But I think I'll just stick to hobby hacking, and pray I never discover a vulnerability. Yikes!

No good deed left unpunished.

QRY commented on LLM Inevitabilism   tomrenner.com/posts/llm-i... · Posted by u/SwoopsFromAbove
godelski · 2 months ago
The problem is Lemon Markets[0]

Lemon Markets do not happen because people do not want "peaches". Lemon markets happen because consumers cannot differentiate a lemon from a peach, at least at time of purchase. There can be high demand for peaches, and even producers of peaches. But if customers can't find out if they bought a lemon or peach until they get home and can take a bite, then peaches disappear.

We do not need a crystal ball to see what is going to happen. We've been watching it happen for more than a decade. We churn out shitty code that is poorly cobbled together, begging for the mercy of death. Yet, despite everyone having computers, phones, and using apps and software, how many can tell what is good and bad without careful inspection?

The bitter truth is that lemons are quick and easy to produce while peaches take time. If we split up software development as you propose, then it won't just be the AI coders who are eating lemons. Frankly, it seems that everything is sour these days. Even the most tech illiterate people I know are frustrated at the sour taste. There's demand for peaches, but it's a hard hole to dig ourselves out of. Even harder when building more shovel factories.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Market_for_Lemons

QRY · 2 months ago
The culpability we share for "churning out shitty code" is spot-on imo. There's been so much incentive to shipping "good enough", that even the definition of "good enough" has been backsliding. Sometimes even to the point of "whatever we can get away with", in the name of speed of delivery.

That friction has always been there, in my experience. But this is the first time I'm seeing it happening around me. LLM's are so divisive, and yet the more extreme positions on either side seem to be digging their heels in, as if the tech is not in flux.

Maybe we need a little Cave Johnson energy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dt6iTwVIiMM

QRY commented on AI Makes It Look Good. Craft Makes It Matter   story.vjy.me/53... · Posted by u/realvjy
sjmog · 2 months ago
AI feels a lot to me like improv. It’s fun to watch, sometimes, and in experienced hands it can even be great - but it’s missing the crafted core of what makes something really good - the “thing” that great art becomes transparent before.
QRY · 2 months ago
Your improv comparison resonates. I'd add that it also reflects the positives of improv. The freedom, being present, lower inhibition/impediments, the positive feedback loop of AI's "yes, and!". These are useful for the same reason improv is to written material. As a sketchbook, trying ideas and really finding the bellylaughs you write into the stage routine.
QRY commented on Backlog.md – Markdown‑native Task Manager and Kanban visualizer for any Git repo   github.com/MrLesk/Backlog... · Posted by u/mrlesk
QRY · 2 months ago
Ooh, definitely trying this out! I ended up homebrewing a whole context maintainance ritual, but that was a pain to get an AI agent to consistently apply, so it spun out into building a whole project management... thing.

This looks much more thought out, thanks for sharing!

QRY commented on Opencode: AI coding agent, built for the terminal   github.com/sst/opencode... · Posted by u/indigodaddy
xrd · 2 months ago
Isn't it more appropriate to compare this to aider?

I prefer the command line tools to IDE integration, even though I don't feel like the contextual options are great. In other words, I don't always feel that I can see the changes fully. I like Claude Code's option to expand the result using ctrl-r, and I like the diffs it provides. But, it still feels like there is a way to get better than what I see inside Zed and what I see inside Claude and Aider.

Maybe an editor that can be controlled and modified on the fly using natural language?

QRY · 2 months ago
That's an interesting idea! I struggle with the same issues you've mentioned, that space between the IDE integrated option and pure CLI. Your comment sparked an idea of using something like vim or similar where you can edit the config on the fly and reload it. I wonder how hard it would be to bolt a prompt interface to the front to have it build the editor for you?

It would likely quickly devolve into typical editor config bikeshedding, only AI powered? At least for me, maybe someone smarter could streamline it enough to be useful though!

QRY commented on Homegrown Closures for Uxn   krzysckh.org/b/Homegrown-... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
apitman · 2 months ago
If you've never heard of Uxn I highly recommend reading this: https://100r.co/site/weathering_software_winter.html
QRY · 2 months ago
My aspirational heroes! There's so many people underserved by our current level of technology, and for no good reason other than what I imagine is "business sense"? What are we doing with all this tech if it can't reach so many? Did we really advance as a species? I lose so much of current tech if I take a walk in the woods, it's ridiculous.

Even just keeping their views in mind as I'm learning and experimenting, I'm noticing there's so much cloud-dependence without good reason, beyond "convience"? Really glad to have discovered their work early in my career, it's been nothing but quality learning!

I don't want to be bound to the "modern world" and its city centers. I want to see the rest of it too, to stray from the fire of a broadcast tower without being left in the cold. I have a torch, I just need to light it.

u/QRY

KarmaCake day20July 20, 2023
About
https://qry.zone/
View Original