Readit News logoReadit News
Onewildgamer commented on Why LLMs can't really build software   zed.dev/blog/why-llms-can... · Posted by u/srid
layer8 · 13 days ago
I suspect that context can’t fully replace a mental model, because context is in-band, in the same band, as all input the LLM receives. It’s all just a linear token sequence that is taken in uniformly. There’s too little structure, and everything is equally subject to being discarded or distorted within the model. Even if parts of that token sequence remains unchanged (a “stable” context) when iterating over input, the input it is surrounded with can have arbitrary downstream effects within the model, making it more unreliable and unstable than mental models are.
Onewildgamer · 13 days ago
Okay I see now. I'm just shooting in the dark here, if there's an ability to generate the next best token based on the trained set of words. Can it be taken a level up, in a meta level to generate a generation? like genetic programming does. Or is that what the chain of thought reasoning models do?

Maybe I need to do more homework on LLMs in general.

Onewildgamer commented on Why LLMs can't really build software   zed.dev/blog/why-llms-can... · Posted by u/srid
Onewildgamer · 13 days ago
I wonder if some of this can be solved by removing some wrongly setup context in LLM. Or get a short summary, restructure it and againt feed to a fresh LLM context.
Onewildgamer commented on AI is propping up the US economy   bloodinthemachine.com/p/t... · Posted by u/mempko
tripletao · 22 days ago
> Do note that peak spending on rail roads eventually amounted to ~20 percent of the US GDP in the 19th century.

Has anyone found the source for that 20%? Here's a paper I found:

> Between 1848 and 1854, railroad investment, in these and in preceding years, contributed to 4.31% of GDP. Overall, the 1850s are the period in which railroad investment had the most substantial contribution to economic conditions, 2.93% of GDP, relative to 2.51% during the 1840s and 2.49% during the 1830s, driven by the much larger investment volumes during the period.

https://economics.wm.edu/wp/cwm_wp153.pdf

The first sentence isn't clear to me. Is 4.31 > 2.93 because the average was higher from 1848-1854 than from 1850-1859, or because the "preceding years" part means they lumped earlier investment into the former range so it's not actually an average? Regardless, we're nowhere near 20%.

I'm wondering if the claim was actually something like "total investment over x years was 20% of GDP for one year". For example, a paper about the UK says:

> At that time, £170 million was close to 20% of GDP, and most of it was spent in about four years.

https://www-users.cse.umn.edu/~odlyzko/doc/mania18.pdf

That would be more believable, but the comparison with AI spending in a single year would not be meaningful.

Onewildgamer · 21 days ago
So we're much closer to the per year spend US saw during the railroad construction era.

At this rate, I hope we get something useful, public, and reasonably priced infrastructure out of these spending in about 5-8 years just like the railroads.

Onewildgamer commented on Claude Opus 4.1   anthropic.com/news/claude... · Posted by u/meetpateltech
aitchnyu · 22 days ago
No, the rotation of the Earth around its axis did so.
Onewildgamer · 21 days ago
Technically, it Earth's rotation gives us day and night. Doesn't move the calendar, which is through Earth's orbital revolution
Onewildgamer commented on I gave the AI arms and legs then it rejected me   grell.dev/blog/ai_rejecti... · Posted by u/serhack_
senko · 22 days ago
The author should have just asked the friend of a friend for a warm intro instead of trying to go through the main gate.

Sucks, but that's the reality of hiring (and getting hired) in tech in general.

Onewildgamer · 21 days ago
Was wondering something similar, if OP had blogged it earlier when he found claude was using it and re-posted it in HN/reddit it in a sensational way to capture eyes. Maybe through one of the forums he could have got an introduction and a job doing what he loves.

OP still has a chance now, maybe not anthropic, even other competitors can come knocking.

Onewildgamer commented on Ask HN: What software subscriptions are worth paying for?    · Posted by u/helloworlddd
Onewildgamer · a month ago
Claude Pro (Switched from Gemini Pro)

Cloudflare domain, compute, db

Apple 50GB Storage

Google One Premium Family (Storage only, not AI)

Youtube Premium

PS Plus

Cancelled:

Spotify (youtube music is better for my needs)

Google AI

Fantastical - I came full circle to Google Calendar

I've bought quite a few useful mac and ios apps on one time payment. I'm interested in rsync.net and maybe setup a self hosting with my friends and family.

Onewildgamer commented on What to build instead of AI agents   decodingml.substack.com/p... · Posted by u/giuliomagnifico
deadbabe · 2 months ago
A key thing we may be forced to admit someday is that AI agents are really just expensive temporary glue that we use to build services quickly until we have cheaper hard coded functions developed once the AI agent gives us sufficient experience with the scope of the problem domain.
Onewildgamer · 2 months ago
An interesting take, only if the stakes are low when the decisions are wrong. I'm not confident to have an LLM taking decisions for a customer or me. I'd rather have it suggest things to customers, sugesstive actions and some useful insights that user may have overlooked.
Onewildgamer commented on Managing time when time doesn't exist   multiverseemployeehandboo... · Posted by u/TMEHpodcast
TMEHpodcast · 2 months ago
Thank you so much for the kind words—this made my day. Would it be alright if I quoted this on the website? It really captures what the podcast aims for.
Onewildgamer · 2 months ago
Certainly, it's an honour to be quantum entangled into the timeless archives of the internet
Onewildgamer commented on Managing time when time doesn't exist   multiverseemployeehandboo... · Posted by u/TMEHpodcast
TMEHpodcast · 2 months ago
OP here. This is a blog post for a science comedy podcast, so the science is accurate but delivered with about 47% more workplace humour than you'd find in Physical Review Letters.

The core premise is based on real, cutting-edge physics research, though it's still an active area of debate.

The Page-Wootters mechanism (proposed in 1983, experimentally validated by Moreva et al. in 2013-2015) does show that time can emerge from quantum entanglement between subsystems. In their experiments, time exists for observers inside entangled quantum systems but not for external observers viewing the whole system.

The Wheeler-DeWitt equation really does lack a time parameter, creating what physicists call the "Problem of Time" in quantum gravity. And there is genuine convergence across string theory, loop quantum gravity, and causal set theory toward "emergent spacetime" models.

However, this doesn't mean time is "fake", it suggests time might be like temperature, which is real and measurable but emerges from more fundamental processes (molecular motion). The research indicates time could emerge from quantum information rather than being a fundamental dimension.

The 2023-2025 research I mentioned (cosmological time dilation measurements, atomic clock advances) is real, though the interpretation that "consciousness creates time" is more speculative than the underlying quantum mechanics. So yes, "emergent time" is a serious scientific hypothesis with experimental support, but science is still figuring out exactly what that means for our understanding of reality.

Onewildgamer · 2 months ago
I was grinning ear to ear reading this, laughed together with a co-worker. What a brilliant, beautiful, thought provoking, ridiculous genius of a comedy.

Thank you, I felt both my intelligent and comic parts of the brain were hanging out in a bar.

Onewildgamer commented on ChatGPT's enterprise success against Copilot fuels OpenAI/Microsoft rivalry   bloomberg.com/news/articl... · Posted by u/mastermaq
Onewildgamer · 2 months ago
Our management introduced copilot last year, there was some mild hype, people were curious, gave it a spin, but it didn’t stick around in many conversations.

Now that everyone has access to Claude and claude-code, Copilot barely gets mentioned anymore. Maybe this wave dies down or they improve it, anyway these tools still have a long long way to go.

u/Onewildgamer

KarmaCake day149March 16, 2014View Original