Readit News logoReadit News
JetSetWilly commented on The Ghosts of Gaelic   historytoday.com/archive/... · Posted by u/apollinaire
eamonnsullivan · 4 months ago
I absolutely understand that, but it seems concerned with the same things (preserving a minority language) and there are lots of initiatives in this area all over the U.K. Literally, right next door.
JetSetWilly · 4 months ago
Really the article - despite the headline - spends a long time on the literary history of gaelic in scotland, with a short paragraph at the end on the current status. I doubt the author had time to expand to a review of minority language measures globally, and it didn’t seem to be the main point of it anyway.

And, the situation and standing of gaelic in Ireland and Scotland are quite different. In Ireland, gaelic is strongly associated with the primary, and successful ethnonationalist movement. In Scotland, at the end of the day gaelic is a remnant of a foreign invasion, and is also historically associated with catholicism, so is often seen as the “other”. This makes it more difficult to whip up enthusiasm to learn it, even among die hard Scottish nationalists. This whole situation is quite unlike Ireland and even Wales, it would be at best a distraction in the article.

JetSetWilly commented on The Ghosts of Gaelic   historytoday.com/archive/... · Posted by u/apollinaire
eamonnsullivan · 4 months ago
I find it odd that the article makes almost zero mention of how Ireland is doing with its very closely related form of Gaelic. Ireland has arguably been at least slightly more successful.

Or Wales? Or other minority languages, such as Basque? Just nothing -- not a mention.

It's missing quite a lot of context.

JetSetWilly · 4 months ago
Why? It’s not about ireland - it’s about scotland. Article makes complete sense in a scottish context.
JetSetWilly commented on How the U.S. became a science superpower   steveblank.com/2025/04/15... · Posted by u/groseje
blululu · 4 months ago
Prior to WWII the United States was the world's leading power in terms of Science, Engineering and Industry - not Germany or the British Empire. The reason that Central European scientists fled to America (and not Britain) is because the United States had the scientific, engineering and industrial base to absorb them. Consider some of the major scientific breakthroughs to come out of the US leading up to and coming out of the war: Nylon, Teflon, Synthetic Rubber, Penicillin, Solid State Transistors, Microwave Communication, Information Theory, a Vaccine for Polio... These all would have happened with or without the war and the migration of German scientists (though adding John von Neumann to the mix probably helped move things along).
JetSetWilly · 4 months ago
> Penicillin

Invented and developed in the UK.

> Microwave communication

Lion's share of pre-war advances and development were in various European countries.

> Synthetic Rubber

Developed by Fritz hoffman at the Bayer Laboratory in Germany, 1906

Frankly, your comment is a massive self-own.

JetSetWilly commented on What made the Irish famine so deadly   newyorker.com/magazine/20... · Posted by u/pepys
xinuc · 6 months ago
After some discussion with some friends from the former "colonizer", it just occurred to me that apparently it's very hard for people from those countries to appreciate their countries' role for a lot of massacre, genocide or any man made disaster like this kind of famine. They always find ways to deflect their countries responsibilities with some "reasons", although they generally agree that any kind of genocide is wrong.

I think this is what we witness today too, with some massacres and genocides going on. People from those colonizer countries just can't relate to the victims. Maybe deep down they acknowledge that those genocides are good, or at least necessary, because those things are what brings them prosperity they enjoy today.

JetSetWilly · 6 months ago
“The British” did not genetically engineer the potato blight.

Further, in the 19th century state capacity was small and massive modern style relief programmes were not possible. Despite this, Britain managed to spend a large degree of GDP on relief. Proportionately more than it did on covid response recently, for example.

The reason people deny british culpability for “genocide” is that there was no “genocide” and britain did what it was able to do, to an unprecedented degree in fact. If anything, we should be proud of britain’s response, especially knowing that it would never get aby kind of gratitude for it.

JetSetWilly commented on Roald Dahl on the death of his daughter (2015)   telegraph.co.uk/books/aut... · Posted by u/areoform
jessekv · 6 months ago
Lots of people still think this way about chickenpox, and I have no idea why.

In the US, vaccination for it is prevalent for years now (in a rare win for preventative health there).

Many other countries: "Chickenpox (and risk of shingles) will be good for you..."

JetSetWilly · 6 months ago
You have it the opposite way round. The UK (for example) never gave a chickenpox vaccine because it reasoned to do so increases the risk of shingles, and shingles is more serious than chickenpox. Also chickenpox is so mild that administering a national vaccination programme is of dubious benefit, the money can be more effectively spent elsewhere.

The JCVI might have recently changed recommendation but whether it is worth the cost/benefit is another matter.

JetSetWilly commented on Machine conquest: Jules Verne's technocratic worldmaking   cambridge.org/core/journa... · Posted by u/johntfella
jylam · 10 months ago
Jules Vernes is a notorious misogynist and racist. Read "The Mysterious Island" for instance. He was a product of his time, but clearly not the best one on those grounds.

Also "People in Europe are white" is really something you just hear from people without any European historical culture, and/or people wanting to sell a racist ideology. You have the whole spectrum of colors in Europe, and that's not recent at all. Africa is 30km from Europe, Asia is connected to it, and people travel since before we were modern humans.

JetSetWilly · 10 months ago
You must work in the BBC drama department if you believe that people in Britain, France, Germany etc are not historically and overwhelmingly white.
JetSetWilly commented on The t-test was invented at the Guinness brewery   scientificamerican.com/ar... · Posted by u/rmason
ein0p · a year ago
Really? You’re going to claim that the prosperity of Britain did not come from systematically plundering the rest of the world? Is this what you’re going to go with as your counterpoint?
JetSetWilly · a year ago
It didn't. It came from the Industrial Revolution and a step change in the productivity of british society. Many economic studies have shown that the "Empire" and especially parts of it like India, the African colonies etc were a net negative to Britain economically speaking. This should not be surprising - just as Afghanistan or Iraq were a net negative to the US more recently, but still allowed certain segments of US society (the military industrial complex) to enrich themselves at the expense of other parts.

Probably in 50 or 100 years there will be some Afghan nationalist movement which will be telling everyone that the entirety of US wealth is based on plunder of Afghanistan. That's roughly how it is with India nationalists and Britain today, but of course, it is nonsense.

JetSetWilly commented on How to found a company in Germany: 14 "easy" steps and lots of pain   eidel.io/how-to-found-a-c... · Posted by u/olieidel
anewhnaccount2 · a year ago
The degradation comes from waves of austerity politics by right wing governments. These services are expensive and require staff to keep things going. Austerity ideology dictates that there simply must be inefficiency in public services, and cuts are the cure to this disease since this will cause the public sector to "make do and mend" and end up running more efficiently, rather than having a knock on effect and decrease the quality of the services. This is the policy direction responsible for the fall in the quality of public services in the UK, and for some reason Finland decided this was an excellent idea and is following suit. The SDP patched things up a little bit, but not as fast as things can be torn down.
JetSetWilly · a year ago
Renewing your passport is quick and relatively painless in the UK. Founding a company is also reasonably easy. This reads like you have some chip on your shoulder about "austerity" and are needlessly bringing it up here.
JetSetWilly commented on Thames Tideway Tunnel super sewer completed   bbc.com/news/science-envi... · Posted by u/Brajeshwar
switch007 · a year ago
> Initially expected to cost £4.2bn, the tunnel has ending up costing about £5bn

By modern standards that seems extremely well-costed! What's £800m / 16% these days?

Rivers/sewage is a hot-topic in England at the moment as the water companies are trying to manufacture consent; trying to get bailouts and/or permission to massively raise prices to fix issues they neglected over many years in order to make shareholders happy (yes, water is fully privatised in England, naturally...though I'm not sure if Scotland (where it's publicly owned) is faring any better when it comes to sewage dumping?)

JetSetWilly · a year ago
Scotland is not faring any better at all. It's just that "sewage in waterways" is not measured in Scotland very much. In England they made the mistake of adding lots of sensors to lots of waterways.

u/JetSetWilly

KarmaCake day1499July 19, 2013View Original