Readit News logoReadit News
FrankRay78 commented on Kotlin creator's new language: talk to LLMs in specs, not English   codespeak.dev/... · Posted by u/souvlakee
onion2k · 16 hours ago
Models aren't deterministic - every time you would try to re-apply you'd likely get different output (without feeding the current code into the re-apply and let it just recommend changes)

If the result is always provably correct it doesn't matter whether or not it's different at the code level. People interested in systems like this believe that the outcome of what the code does is infinity more important than the code itself.

FrankRay78 · 15 hours ago
Sure, but where are the formal acceptance tests to validate against?
FrankRay78 commented on Verified Spec-Driven Development (VSDD)   gist.github.com/dollspace... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
FrankRay78 · 12 days ago
No much different from what I did manually when employer outsourced development to India.
FrankRay78 commented on ai;dr   0xsid.com/blog/aidr... · Posted by u/ssiddharth
zahlman · a month ago
> Most people here would not be able to tell the difference between good human and good AI generated writing anymore in a blind test, especially a blend of both. So if the reader often can’t tell

You say that, but I think it's really, really obvious in this case.

If you disagree, you should show us both versions.

FrankRay78 · a month ago
I would be happy to, but let me think about writing it up properly and posting it as a more serious piece for consideration.
FrankRay78 commented on ai;dr   0xsid.com/blog/aidr... · Posted by u/ssiddharth
meindnoch · a month ago
I just skimmed the article, but I can already tell it's chock-full of LLMisms. In other words: ai;dr

Edit: ok, I've checked your profile and now I see that this is your website that you're astroturfing every thread you reply to. Stop doing that.

FrankRay78 · a month ago
I’m seriously not astroturfing, point is serious. Most people here would not be able to tell the difference between good human and good AI generated writing anymore in a blind test, especially a blend of both. So if the reader often can’t tell, why is the source of a well written, interesting piece of writing more important, than the effect of the content itself? I don’t feel the OP made a good argument imho.

u/FrankRay78

KarmaCake day52November 1, 2023View Original