Readit News logoReadit News
FabHK commented on Nature's many attempts to evolve a Nostr   newsletter.squishy.comput... · Posted by u/fiatjaf
FabHK · 2 hours ago
Pet peeve:

> N^2 scaling: if every fed has to talk to every other fed to exchange messages, the number of connections will scale exponentially

No. That's quadratic growth, which is a fairly mild form of polynomial growth, which is much much much slower than exponential growth.

   k   k^2   2^k
   1     1     1
  10   100  1024
 100   1e4  1e30

FabHK commented on An Implementation of J (1992)   jsoftware.com/ioj/ioj.htm... · Posted by u/ofalkaed
lgas · 2 days ago
I think almost everyone is with you on readability, but I think it would be hard to make the case that it lacks power.
FabHK · 2 days ago
Indeed. Read some of the Project Euler discussions (after solving a problem). The J answers tend to be very short and very fast.

Deleted Comment

Deleted Comment

Deleted Comment

FabHK commented on I wasted years of my life in crypto   twitter.com/kenchangh/sta... · Posted by u/Anon84
shuntress · 9 days ago
Git
FabHK · 7 days ago
Git is nice distributed tech. It's permissioned, though. Good old permissioned distributed tech. Which predates Bitcoin (obviously, as git is older than Bitcoin).
FabHK commented on I wasted years of my life in crypto   twitter.com/kenchangh/sta... · Posted by u/Anon84
panzi · 9 days ago
Yeah and even more crazy: all other applications of blockchains are even more stupid. Haven't seen another application that wouldn't have been better, faster, cheaper implemented in a "classical" way.
FabHK · 7 days ago
Agree. Blockchain is good for nothing but crypto (by virtue of the oracle problem, among others), and crypto is good for nothing but crime.

It's funny, people speak as if decentralisation was a good thing, but very few bother to explain why. Typically, if you dig into it, they cite advantages that you can already get from good old permissioned distributed tech. The only thing that decentralisation gets you (at enormous cost) is that it's harder to regulate.

FabHK commented on I wasted years of my life in crypto   twitter.com/kenchangh/sta... · Posted by u/Anon84
l___l · 8 days ago
A different metric of comparison isn't Bitcoin's energy consumption compared to other countries but compared to the existing banking system it's trying to replace, which burns more energy than Bitcoin and allegedly burns more energy funding wars with fiat. Mining gold instead of Bitcoin burns more energy than Bitcoin too.

Compared to that for energy consumption, Bitcoin is superior really.

FabHK · 7 days ago
A bitcoin transaction costs around $100 (in invisible money supply increase, paid by everyone that holds Bitcoin, but received by the miners).

There's no way a fiat transfer costs that much.

FabHK commented on I wasted years of my life in crypto   twitter.com/kenchangh/sta... · Posted by u/Anon84
troupo · 8 days ago
Ah yes. And everyone in a country that suffers a banking collapse lives in a wilderness with solar power and a sattelite uplink.
FabHK · 7 days ago
Yes. And if a country with say 200m people suffered a banking collapse, everyone could do a Bitcoin transaction every 40 days (assuming everyone else stopped using it), and would use only about 1% of the world's electricity. Great stuff.
FabHK commented on I wasted years of my life in crypto   twitter.com/kenchangh/sta... · Posted by u/Anon84
aeternum · 8 days ago
>BSV seemed to scale just fine, and you could also store entire files on it, including JSON, HTML or even music or videos

This doesn't pass the sniff test. Everyone must store the full blockchain in order to verify it. So to run a full node you would have to store everyone's JSON, HTML, music, videos. Full mirroring for every node in a distributed system is about as close as you can get to the definition of doesn't scale.

FabHK · 7 days ago
Indeed. Bitcoin's blockchain grows with a laughable 3kB/s, yet is an unwieldy 700 GB.

A blockchain that allowed you store one song per second would be hundreds of TB before long. There are other architectures for that sort of thing for a reason.

u/FabHK

KarmaCake day15303December 21, 2015
About
Unrepentant ultracrepidarian

http://www.fabian-lischka.de

hackernews@fabian-lischka.de

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/fab; my proof: https://keybase.io/fab/sigs/XVCHiJ8si5GOpHUKjHh8QVkG9Czgvft0ZTZGHmRLnkI ]

Ceterum censeo Elsevier(um) esse delendum.

View Original