Readit News logoReadit News
AndyIsBuilding commented on Ask HN: Good Pocket Alternative    · Posted by u/atulvi
atulvi · 7 months ago
That's great to hear. Original Pocket recommended articles were very high quality. I saved a lot of Haskell/fp related articles back in the day and all my recommendations were related to the topic, saved by other users with my same niche interests.

I'd say this kind of recommendation is not hard to do. Pocket simply went to the dark side for monetization reasons.

This is why I wanted to look for a decentralized alternative that can be self hosted, yet communicates with other nodes for recommendations.

AndyIsBuilding · 7 months ago
Thanks! I'll keep that in mind as I create the rec system. Are there any other issues you've found with using Pocket? Do you still use it at all or is it just a repository of things you've saved but never access (like me until recently)?
AndyIsBuilding commented on Ask HN: Good Pocket Alternative    · Posted by u/atulvi
AndyIsBuilding · 7 months ago
I've build a Pocket alternative and plan to launch soon. It's focused more on usability right now, since Pocket has completely dropped the ball on so many fronts, but usability is my biggest grievance.

The recommendation engine has yet to be built so would love to hear more about what you liked best.

AndyIsBuilding commented on Ask HN: Why don't you use spaced repetition to learn, despite its effectiveness?    · Posted by u/AndyIsBuilding
muzani · 10 months ago
Because it's not the most effective way to learn; it's the most effective way to not forget.

Here's an article by the person who discovered SR: https://www.supermemo.com/en/blog/twenty-rules-of-formulatin...

To do it effectively, you'd have to have learned everything in advance and processed the knowledge in a format suited to SR. The processing itself makes it ineffective. For many things, 30% retention is good enough. It would cost more to read a book deeply with SR than to read several books shallowly without it.

If only there was a fix for that? Well, spaced repetition was designed to work in tandem with incremental reading. Which is you jump around topics related to your topic and extract the most relevant details.

People seem to have adopted only half of the pair, which is why it feels so inefficient. Supermemo was actually very efficient with this... except that it's reliant on Internet Explorer and now breaks on all modern OSes and doesn't even run on Mac. For some reason, people were able to rewrite SR into Anki, but not the incremental reading part.

However, AI seems to be taking on this role quite well. It's capable of not only incremental reading, but also processing the data into spaced repetition format. But I'll just wait for someone to build this.

AndyIsBuilding · 10 months ago
Good points.

On not forgetting, the clear group here are students who will be tested. I'm expecting large changes in education in the next 10 years away from testing and more toward experiential learning with clearly defined outcomes, which are then graded/measured.

So while I use SR to learn and test myself, I'm trying to think through the use cases for a different future that isn't 100% likely to materialize.

AndyIsBuilding commented on Ask HN: Why don't you use spaced repetition to learn, despite its effectiveness?    · Posted by u/AndyIsBuilding
aristofun · 10 months ago
I guess because it's the method to _memorize_ things, not learn.

And IRL you rarely need to bluntly memorize stuff, even in foreign languages.

AndyIsBuilding · 10 months ago
This was one of my original views, but I've since changed my mind. I agree in the sense that one of the few times you'd need pure memorization is for testing.

However, the top comment from a recent article here [0] put it into perspective. For a lot of people, regularly being reminded of the fundamentals helps them overcome whatever prevents them from grokking something from the outset. For really difficult concepts (something that varies for everyone), I believe that regular memorization and repetition can help you learn over time.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40167163

AndyIsBuilding commented on Ask HN: Why don't you use spaced repetition to learn, despite its effectiveness?    · Posted by u/AndyIsBuilding
s1110 · 10 months ago
Please tell us about your experience of using spaced repetition.
AndyIsBuilding · 10 months ago
Often you'll see comments about how SR is most effective when you create your own cards and that using off-the-shelf cards isn't effective. But what I've found is that the biggest barrier to using it is the card creation itself. If I have cards in a system, whether it's Anki or otherwise, I am pretty consistent and find that I recall the information in my notes far easier.

I think there's a credibility/trust issue, though, with taking other people's card decks and using them, assuming the info is accurate.

AndyIsBuilding commented on Ask HN: How do you keep track of “Log in with” accounts    · Posted by u/AndyIsBuilding
markx2 · a year ago
I use Bitwarden but have used LastPass and 1Password before.

I always, without exception, will sign up with a username & password. I would never use a"Log in with". To me, if I am logging in through a different company then it is that company who has control, not me. There are tales here and elsewhere when Google has nuked someone's account. That's bad, but if you logged in with Google on other sites then you are completely screwed. Same applies to other companies.

I won't be using the Apple Passwords app.

AndyIsBuilding · a year ago
I've read some of these tales here as well. I'm thinking more about how to migrate from "log in with" to a un/pwd
AndyIsBuilding commented on Ask HN: Roast My Startup    · Posted by u/vbond
vbond · 2 years ago
Well, I have some confidence in the problem - people do forget things, pretty much everyone does...

Compared to Notion where you need to organize your stuff (if you're using it for private notes) - Remindful takes this extra work away.

You just store anything and then ask to recall it back.

This is based on the assumption that many people are not great at organizing their data.

Does this make sense to you?

AndyIsBuilding · 2 years ago
Indeed your view makes sense. I'm very much one of the people you mention, I forget things all the time, and use search in Notion to find the things most relevant to me. I also don't over-organize my notes, but rather use something simple much like the PARA method[0], and so would challenge the organization piece of your argument.

To me, the value proposition would be anything incremental you can provide above and beyond simple search, but also something that isn't broadly accessible through other means (web search, GPT-like solutions, etc)

[0] https://fortelabs.com/blog/para/

AndyIsBuilding commented on Ask HN: Roast My Startup    · Posted by u/vbond
AndyIsBuilding · 2 years ago
Nice work getting this out there!

>> I'm guessing this is in the category of "Productivity Apps", the closest competitors seems to be apps like Evernote

This is the part that stood out to me most. You seem unsure of your competitors and so you'll have limited understanding of your market and target customers. I'd start by validating the user's problem and then ensuring the product does that.

As a heavy Notion user, I'd also be curious how I can leverage what I've already built there.

u/AndyIsBuilding

KarmaCake day8November 15, 2021View Original