Readit News logoReadit News
2snakes commented on A non-anthropomorphized view of LLMs   addxorrol.blogspot.com/20... · Posted by u/zdw
orbital-decay · 2 months ago
>I am baffled by seriously intelligent people imbuing almost magical human-like powers to something that - in my mind - is just MatMul with interspersed nonlinearities.

I am baffled by seriously intelligent people imbuing almost magical powers that can never be replicated to to something that - in my mind - is just a biological robot driven by a SNN with a bunch of hardwired stuff. Let alone attributing "human intelligence" to a single individual, when it's clearly distributed between biological evolution, social processes, and individuals.

>something that - in my mind - is just MatMul with interspersed nonlinearities

Processes in all huge models (not necessarily LLMs) can be described using very different formalisms, just like Newtonian and Lagrangian mechanics describe the same stuff in physics. You can say that an autoregressive model is a stochastic parrot that learned the input distribution, next token predictor, or that it does progressive pathfinding in a hugely multidimensional space, or pattern matching, or implicit planning, or, or, or... All of these definitions are true, but only some are useful to predict their behavior.

Given all that, I see absolutely no problem with anthropomorphizing an LLM to a certain degree, if it makes it easier to convey the meaning, and do not understand the nitpicking. Yeah, it's not an exact copy of a single Homo Sapiens specimen. Who cares.

2snakes · 2 months ago
There is this thing called Brahman in Hinduism that is interesting to juxtapose when it comes to sentience, and monism.
2snakes commented on Bohemians at the Gate?   inferencemagazine.substac... · Posted by u/surprisetalk
niemandhier · 3 months ago
I live in walking distance from the place the brothers Grimm sourced their version of Snow White.

Ai image generator frequently refuse to create illustrations featuring the character, everybody is afraid of Disney.

Similar, Disney’s Winnie the Puh just looks like Magarete Steiffs plush bear with a red shirt.

Very often those who claim to have created an original work themselves just produced derivatives, at least those should not be protected to the detriment of humankind.

2snakes · 3 months ago
Pooh. Winnie the Pooh. <3
2snakes commented on The hidden cost of AI coding   terriblesoftware.org/2025... · Posted by u/Sharpie4679
iamleppert · 4 months ago
There's nothing stopping you from coding if you enjoy it. It's not like they have taken away your keyboard. I have found that AI frees me up to focus on the parts of coding I'm actually interested in, which is maybe 5-10% of the project. The rest is boiler plate, cargo-culted, Dockerfile, build system and bash environment variable passing circle of hell that I really could care less about. I care about certain things that I know will make the product better, and achieve its goals in a clever and satisfying way.

Even when I'm stuck in hell, fighting the latest undocumented change in some obscure library or other grey-bearded creation, the LLM, although not always right, is there for me to talk to, when before I'd often have no one. It doesn't judge or sneer at you, or tell you to "RTFM". It's better than any human help, even if its not always right because its at least always more reliable and you don't have to bother some grey beard who probably hates you anyway.

2snakes · 4 months ago
I read one characterization which is that LLMs don't give new information (except to the user learning) but they reorganize old information.
2snakes commented on How I blog with Obsidian, Hugo, GitHub, and Cloudflare   ingau.me/blog/how-i-write... · Posted by u/ingav
packetlost · 4 months ago
The one issue I have with Obsidian Publish is it's a bit of a pain to put your own SSL-secured domain in front of it. I run a nginx-based proxy as a bandage. I can see why someone would not want to pay $8/m for it though when there are a ton of free options out there. You have to remember that devs love flexing their skills and automating a blog can be fun, it's not really anything wrong with the service.
2snakes · 4 months ago
-Your own- yes, but Cloudflare is extremely easy.
2snakes commented on AI 2027   ai-2027.com/... · Posted by u/Tenoke
visarga · 5 months ago
I think you are underestimating the context, we all stand on shoulders of giants. Let's think what would happen if kid Einstein, at the young age of 5, was marooned on an island and recovered 30 years later. Will he have any deep insights to dazzle us with? I don't think he would.
2snakes · 5 months ago
Hayy ibn Yaqdhan Nature vs nurture and relative nature of intelligence iirc
2snakes commented on The hallucinatory thoughts of the dying mind   thereader.mitpress.mit.ed... · Posted by u/anarbadalov
wutwutwat · 7 months ago
That has what to do with this person saying a death is sad?
2snakes · 7 months ago
Bodies and minds can be transcended beyond suffering.
2snakes commented on The hallucinatory thoughts of the dying mind   thereader.mitpress.mit.ed... · Posted by u/anarbadalov
wutwutwat · 7 months ago
Please describe what makes one's death a "sad death"
2snakes · 7 months ago
Real yoga is possible.
2snakes commented on Being overweight overtakes tobacco smoking as the leading disease risk factor   scimex.org/newsfeed/being... · Posted by u/giuliomagnifico
caffeinated_me · 9 months ago
Any recommendations on telehealth suppliers to contact for that compounded formulation? They're easy to find, but I'm not sure who is trustworthy on this topic.
2snakes · 9 months ago
Mochi / Henry Meds. Mochi is the cheapest.
2snakes commented on The 70% problem: Hard truths about AI-assisted coding   addyo.substack.com/p/the-... · Posted by u/mooreds
2snakes · 9 months ago
One thing that LLM can do besides generate code is explain complex code too. So that is inherently an upskilling feature.

u/2snakes

KarmaCake day90October 26, 2014View Original