Readit News logoReadit News
tptacek · 23 days ago
Are these LLM-generated causes of death? There are a couple startups here where I'm somewhat familiar with the "real" causes of death and the stated cause here is just fluff.
dadrian · 23 days ago
Some of them also aren't really dead.
gkoberger · 23 days ago
I guess I don't see the problem? Nothing lasts forever, and everyone involved knew the risks.

That money wasn't purely wasted, it went into salaries and other products. At least half ended in exits and became a part of another company.

The ability to fail and fail big is what makes the SF tech scene special... people aren't afraid to try something audacious. And sure, the world could take-or-leave most of these products, but I don't really see the point in this negative framing.

jabedude · 23 days ago
I don't think this website is implying there was a 'problem' per se. In fact it seems to be geared towards helping resurrect the original premises
Kkoala · 22 days ago
"Where $32.5B+ in venture capital was burned to ashes." isn't exactly a positive spin.

At least the copy seems AI-generated though, so I guess can't read too much into it.

forkLding · 23 days ago
Club Penguin was sold to Disney for 350 million, it didn't die in the sense that money ran out
giancarlostoro · 23 days ago
I was going to say, I don't see Club Penguin as a total failure. Heck, there's a dozen or more Club Penguin private servers. Don't let your children on them though, I hear they've got the same pedophilia problem as Roblox.
Oras · 23 days ago
There are a few startups that were acquired, not sure if the acquisition had covered the investment, as it's not clear.

- Pebble

- Udemy

- Viper

klik99 · 23 days ago
I think it's a great idea to highlight that companies that fail in the VC context aren't necessarily bad ideas for companies - there is just a specific business model that thrives with VC funding (extremely high scalability, reliable unit costs) and companies that don't fit that or fail to develop in that direction may still be great businesses but get driven into the ground by VCs trying to find the one unicorn out of 15 in the profile.
tracker1 · 23 days ago
Agreed, there's nothing at all wrong with a company that has a comfortable market fit than makes a pretty consistent $X/yr with Y employees/staff. Not everything needs to be the next big VC Unicorn. A lot of these ideas could very well be multi-million dollar businesses with a little effort.
njudah · 23 days ago
As they say, I'm not dead yet -- many of the companies listed as dead are acquired or very much still alive. (Domo is still publicly traded, for example.)
defaultcompany · 23 days ago
Poshmark also is not dead.
mbesto · 23 days ago
Some of these still exist, I don't get it? What dictates when a company is "dead"? Insolvency? Bankruptcy?

For example - Domo is still publicly traded and does $300M in revenue:

https://www.cnbc.com/quotes/DOMO

siliconc0w · 23 days ago
Some of these are acquires so it's hard to argue the money was 'burned'. That said I do agree acquired companies can be viable as the product usually gets put on life-support or ruined/shutdown (like Club Penguin)
raincole · 23 days ago
Even the products got eventually shut down I still don't think the money was necessarily 'burned.' Most buildings eventually fell or got destructed so were all the resources spent on construction burned? But whether a product actually helped the users is a question too nuance to ask.
foobiekr · 23 days ago
A lot of acquisitions are tech and talent and the details matter. A startup that gets acquired for $30M after burning $70M is definitely burned.
mushufasa · 23 days ago
this type of resource is actually super useful to idea-stage founders, as it can often be hard to research failed attempts at a domain (typically the websites and assets disappear over time). Even just an index is helpful.

In glancing through this list, some of these make me go "hmm." For example, MySpace is an entry. While it did eventually die, I'm not sure I personally would count myspace as a startup failure -- it got to huge scale, got acquired, and still had niche activity for many years of gradual decline post-acquisition. Certainly, the startup founders and investors had a successful exit.