Readit News logoReadit News
Posted by u/jeanlucas 2 months ago
Tell HN: Google ignores English searches and forces localized results
Google Search change in a way that I can’t seem to opt out of.

I’m based in a non-English-speaking country, but I regularly search in English, especially for technical topics.

My Google account, my laptop, my phone, my interface language, and preferences are all set to English; only my physical location and payment methods are local.

What happens is that Google increasingly returns localized results in my native language and aggressively applies automatic translation.

Some concrete behaviors I’m seeing:

- Queries written in English still prioritize pages in Portuguese, even when equivalent English sources exist.

- Reddit results are often force-translated instead of linking to the original English content.

- “AI mode” responses are always in Portuguese, even when the prompt is clearly in English, with no visible way to force output language.

- The UI offers a choice between “Portuguese” and “All web,” but selecting “All web” doesn’t reliably return English results nor disable translation.

- In practice, explicit query language seems to be overridden by inferred user preferences (location / account language).

I’m curious whether others are seeing the same behavior, and whether there’s any way to restore search to become 100% useful again; or what are you using since this really limits search results, especially for technical things.

tambourine_man · 2 months ago
Google is institutionally incapable of understanding that some people can speak multiple languages. Only reliable solution I found is to create one account for each language and restrict the number of available languages to just that one in:

https://www.google.com/preferences?lang=1

YouTube is the worst offender these days. I get Portuguese videos auto-dubbed to English and vice-versa even though I can understand both and with no way to disable other than account switching.

It also can't tell Portuguese from Spanish in search queries.

out_of_protocol · 2 months ago
You also need a VPN, otherwise you'll get results in local language anyway
orloffm · 2 months ago
You can now select languages to not auto-translate in YouTube settings.
jhart99 · 2 months ago
I didn't realize they finally added a way to sort of control this behavior. It's under Languages in the YouTube settings. Similarly there is a control for captions languages under Captions/Subtitles.
pentagrama · 2 months ago
To avoid YouTube auto-dubbing I use https://youtube-no-translation.vercel.app/

Recommended!

franciscop · 2 months ago
I have the same problem and my "solution" is mediocre, but kind of works: use a VPN. I used to set it to the UK, but since the recent developments I've been experimenting with other English-speaking countries. My native language is Spanish, but I live in Japan, and it's odd because I never want Japanese (language) results, but I am fine with Spanish results.

Some times I need to switch to Spain, or Japan, or just disable it due to geo blocking. I use Mullvad, which makes this easier, but TBH the main practical use of my VPN is what you mention, I never want results in Japanese and Google is very bad at getting the hint.

The worst one I keep noticing is MDN, I know there's an article in perfectly fine English but why am I always redirected to the local language one? That's not even location-dependent.

jeanlucas · 2 months ago
Japan is an entire situation to me as well, Google completely walls off results in Japanese, even when I specifically want it. Sometimes I need to search things in English, but on the Japanese web and for that I think VPN might be the only way.

I run a small personal VPN, but not one of these company solutions, might be time to do that.

estebarb · 2 months ago
Not only search: titles and description of Youtube videos are being translated. Colab UI is now in Spanish (using technical terms that make no sense).

Some people may want translation, mostly people that only speak a single language. But for most bilingual people, being forced a translation (a lower quality one), is a worse experience. I'm surprised that no one at Google has pushed back this anti-user behavior. It is like no one at Google knows more than one language.

The worst part is when traveling. Google ignores the browser settings, so it throws me Japanese or German website, even if my browser settings clearly says English then Spanish.

petre · 2 months ago
> The worst part is when traveling.

They are trying so hard to be smart that the Chrome locale is determined from your GPS location, which creates obvious problems. I tried to change it once using the Sensors in dev tools in order to get rid of the AM/PM in time input fields, to no avail. You do not simply get the 24h time format.

jjaksic · 2 months ago
FWIW, I once complained about this and they told me it's a "hard problem".
shadowgovt · 2 months ago
Google has a lot of data to see how the average user uses computers. The problem is, that data tells them that the number of people who misconfigure their localization settings (or can't configure them; shared computer) is way larger than the people using those settings on purpose to try and request non-local results. So they err far, far on the side of using your location as a signal of intent over your machine and browser configuration.

ETA: https://www.google.com/advanced_search appears to give options for tuning your language and region in the search results. I haven't used it personally in ages, but it may give you what you're looking for.

jeanlucas · 2 months ago
Your comment makes sense to me and it feels like a Windows trade-off: optimizing for the average user while eroding power-user controls; Mark Russinovich has talked about the need for explicit, advanced modes instead of burying power-user behavior behind heuristics in one of his videos about what he would change in Windows.

Google could benefit from the same idea: an expert mode where explicit signals override inference with genuinely usable advanced search features (language, filters, etc) as first-class tools.

antiloper · 2 months ago
If you don't want to pay for Kagi: https://duckduckgo.com/
Imustaskforhelp · 2 months ago
Let me add a few more search providers

brave search ecosia (environment focused) qwant mojeek (a little bit obscure) swisscows (once again obscure)

There is also searx and searxng and their public instances which actually are a mix of many of the search providers I listed about.

Giving references to anyone whose interested perhaps but duckduckgo is a good option to start out and its something that I myself use.

hulitu · 2 months ago
> If you don't want to pay for Kagi: https://duckduckgo.com/

It is the same shit. Dear duckduckgo, when I ask for results in English (or in other language), I mean it.

It looks like those days Google and duckduckgo are also hallucinating. You aske some terms, in a specific order, and get something which has no relation, whatsoever, with the search query.

coffeefirst · 2 months ago
I have the opposite problem with YouTube, where they insist on dubbing everything when in just want subtitles.

The result is an Italian cooking demo where the chef exclaims “MULTA BENE!” and the AI voice deadpans “it is very good.”

I’m sure it’s even more annoying when you’re bilingual and can’t turn it off.

jeanlucas · 2 months ago
>I’m sure it’s even more annoying when you’re bilingual and can’t turn it off.

At least on this point now it is possible to turn it off.

coffeefirst · 2 months ago
Did they add a global setting somewhere? When I encountered it you had to change it on each video.
xeeeeeeeeeeenu · 2 months ago
>Reddit results are often force-translated instead of linking to the original English content.

It's very annoying. Put this in a search query to filter them out: -inurl:?tl=

theodric · 2 months ago
I built a Firefox extension to inject this sort of thing automatically, but I'm not sure if I'm allowed to shill it here. It's not like I'm getting paid for it...
Imustaskforhelp · 2 months ago
hey! Quick suggestion but if you create an firefox extension, please open source it. It immensely boosts my trust in an extension and I doubt that it would be considered a shill (atleast in my book) if you open source it and I don't think that you earn from the extension but if its open source and people like it, it opens up a pathway where people can donate if this extension helps their problems!
Qem · 2 months ago
Same problem. My workaround is to use Yandex instead. In my experience it's consistently returning more relevant results than Google for some time already, and there's less censorship while searching torrent related content.
linhns · 2 months ago
Yandex is utter shit. I’m annoyed by Google giving localized results first but at least they are results, Yandex churns out nothingburgers