Readit News logoReadit News
xdfgh1112 · 2 months ago
Abandoned for a new project. Kuzu is Japanese for unwanted/useless scraps or garbage, so I suppose it's still living up to its name.
jlund-molfese · 2 months ago
For anyone who's curious—the project was originally named after the Sumerian word for "wisdom"[1].

1. https://web.archive.org/web/20250318034702/https://blog.kuzu...

NewJazz · 2 months ago
Wow the Japanese were pretty savage back then.
avree · 2 months ago
The kana spelling (which is what phonetically would sound like 'kuzu') can refer to either scraps/garbage, or the Kudzu plant.

Dead Comment

m00dy · 2 months ago
Kuzu means sheep in turkish.
aaa_aaa · 2 months ago
Not sheep, lamb.
redpink · 2 months ago
gitlab just announced knowledge graph with kuzu db. i wonder how it will turns out
jabr · 2 months ago
A couple companies using Kuzu in products are talking about joining efforts on a community fork, including Gitlab and Kineviz. Possible future home of that work: https://github.com/Kineviz/bighorn
gkorland · 2 months ago
can you share a link?
nrjames · 2 months ago
I've been excited about Kuzu DB as a SQLite-style graph database. It looks like the devs are moving on to something else and no longer will support it, as of 10 October.

Their message reads, "Kuzu is working on something new! We will no longer be actively supporting KuzuDB. You can access the full archive of KuzuDB here: GitHub" https://github.com/kuzudb/kuzu

scosman · 2 months ago
Oh too bad. Small fast embedded graph DBs are rare. Any good alternatives?
n_u · 2 months ago
There was a recent VLDB paper[1] demonstrating that the extension DuckPGQ[2] for DuckDB (an embedded database) offers competitive graph query performance compared to Neo4j and Umbra. No data on how it compares to KuzuDB.

[1] https://vldb.org/cidrdb/papers/2023/p66-wolde.pdf [2] https://duckpgq.org/

luizfelberti · 2 months ago
There used to be a similarly names one called CozoDB[0] which was pretty awesome but it looks like its development significantly slowed down.

[0] https://github.com/cozodb/cozo

gkorland · 2 months ago
You should check FalkorDB https://github.com/falkordb/falkordb
scosman · 2 months ago
Not embedded last I checked. Unless that changed.
joestrouth1 · 2 months ago
Oxigraph[1] is an option, though it's RDF/SPARQL-based rather than property graph/cypher

1. https://github.com/oxigraph/oxigraph

scosman · 2 months ago
Another potential one: new and not ready for primetime yet, but from the Lance team so it's promising: https://github.com/lancedb/lance-graph
lmeyerov · 2 months ago
Posted below: GFQL is also OSS and architecturally similar, though slightly different goals and features: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45560036#45561807
nchmy · 2 months ago
Perhaps dgraph if using go. Or surrealdb, though it's the opposite of small - it's an all in one, do everything db. I'm excited to see how it matures
greyhard · 2 months ago
scosman · 2 months ago
“Cloud native” - not embedded
SoftTalker · 2 months ago
Fork it and organize support for it.
NewJazz · 2 months ago
Someone linked to some duckdb extension above that shows some graph support.
OutOfHere · 2 months ago
If I can't trust their first project (KuzuDB), then why on earth would I trust any subsequent project by them? I won't.

This is why I stick to SQLite or PostgreSQL when it comes to databases. An LLM can trivially write me the commonly necessary graph queries if I should need them.

jabr · 2 months ago
My best guess is the company was acqui-hired and will soon be working on implementing Kuzu's tech in a different database owned by the acquirer.

My _hope_ is that it was some IP issue with the University of Waterloo and a new company will appear shortly and pretty much pick up where they left off, but that's probably just wishful thinking on my part.

SoftTalker · 2 months ago
Why does an MIT-licensed open source project owe you anything whatsoever?
rowanG077 · 2 months ago
How did you interpret this person comment as about being owed anything? It's simply a fact of life that it's not smart to put your eggs into an unstable basket.
OutOfHere · 2 months ago
It's not about what is owed; it's about what can be trusted. The people behind Kuzu have shown that they cannot be trusted to be used.
adsharma · 2 months ago
NewJazz · 2 months ago
Note that the repo mentions "some of our resources are moving from our website to GitHub: "Docs: http://kuzudb.github.io/docs, Blog: http://kuzudb.github.io/blog" but those links currently redirect to kuzudb.com. I presume they won't be covering the domain name costs in the future and that the transition is in-progress.
nrjames · 2 months ago
They already took it down, unfortunately.
Ultimatt · 2 months ago
dtenwolde · 2 months ago
Hi there, leading DuckPGQ developer here :) Thanks for the shoutout! I've been busy working on an internship at DuckDB labs so DuckPGQ has gotten less attention, but I'll get back to it soon (December most likely) and will update the extension to support DuckDB v1.4.0 and v1.4.1 this week hopefully.
adsharma · 2 months ago
PGQ requires you to write using SQL and read using a graph query language. GQL is a standalone language that supports reads/writes. But much of the community is still using cypher.

More on this here:

https://adsharma.github.io/beating-the-CAP-theorem-for-graph...

aftbit · 2 months ago
As far as I can tell, this has nothing to do with CAP theorem or distributed systems. It's just being used as an analogy.

> [CAP theorem] states that any distributed storage system can provide only two of these three guarantees: Consistency, Availability and Partition safety.

> In the realm of graph databases, we observe a similar “two out three” situation. You can either have scalable systems that are not fully open source or you can have open source systems designed for small graphs. Details below.

(the article follows)

> This is one solution to the CAP theorem for graphs. We can store a billion scale graph using this method in parquet files and use a free, cheap and open source solution to traverse them, perform joins without storage costs that are prohibitively high.

adsharma · 2 months ago
The code to implement this was open sourced today:

https://github.com/LadybugDB/ladybug/pull/3

jabr · 2 months ago
DuckPGQ is an interesting option, but unfortunately, that project hasn't been touched in a few months and does not currently work with the latest version of DuckDB.
dtenwolde · 2 months ago
Hi there, leading DuckPGQ developer here. I've been busy with other projects but will get back to it soon enough :)
mark_l_watson · 2 months ago
I use the Python Kuzu graph database library, super convenient for local experiments. I see no reason to stop using it. The underlying database is archived on GitHub so it isn’t going anywhere.
adsharma · 2 months ago
One thing you might want to watch out for is that the storage format on disk is not stabilized.

Last few releases, you couldn't open a file written by a previous version of kuzu. You had to constantly export/import as new versions were released.

This is no longer a problem for kuzu because development has stopped. But any open source fork needs to think about how to stabilize storage.

In the past few releases kuzu switched from database as a directory to a single file database.