Readit News logoReadit News
traveler1 · a year ago
Whilst this is theoretically a nice idea for security/privacy, wouldn’t there be throughput/latency concerns over mobile networks if you aren’t just connecting to one server and getting all your notifications in one go? One of the biggest slow downs on mobile data is the initial handshake, so repeating that for each of your apps doesn’t seem worth the trade off to me.
hollow-moe · a year ago
This is the goal, in the same way Google does for FCM: the Play Services maintain a connection with their servers to get the notifications and then send them to the different apps. Here's it's the same with a server you control and know it won't read whatever is in that notification, without draining the battery because there's only the Unified Push app maintaining the connection.
GranPC · a year ago
> know it won't read whatever is in that notification,

Aren't notification contents E2E? The website is rather light on details.

dang · a year ago
Related. Others?

Conversations (XMPP Client) is now a UnifiedPush distributor - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34381598 - Jan 2023 (30 comments)

UnifiedPush: A decentralized, open-source push notification protocol - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34094497 - Dec 2022 (146 comments)

mmwelt · a year ago
A pity that iOS doesn't support UnifiedPush and probably won't in the foreseeable future[1].

[1] https://unifiedpush.org/users/faq/#will-unifiedpush-ever-wor...

jqpabc123 · a year ago
This essentially kills it's utility for a lot of use cases.
KetoManx64 · a year ago
Does it? If you're using an iPhone are you really expecting to be able to use a third party project like this for notificatioms with how locked down IOS is and Apple's limitations on what is allowed to be installed on your device?
mothergreen · a year ago
this whole mess could be solved by mobile network operators giving every device a static IPv6, which the services can directly send packets to.

you know, just how the Internet Protocol was originally intended.

Ruthalas · a year ago
I would love for RocketChat to support UnifiedPush. It seems like such good fit.
sneak · a year ago
Isn’t ntfy run purely best-effort for free by one person as a hobby?
KetoManx64 · a year ago
There is paid plans for extra message limits and other features: https://ntfy.sh/#pricing

Deleted Comment