Readit News logoReadit News
psychphysic · 3 years ago
Interesting article, but I wish OPs would give us a comment on what made it worth sharing to them.
PlasmonOwl · 3 years ago
Yeah I mean this is high-school level chemistry, right?
icepat · 3 years ago
Essentially yes, what's a bit more interesting is Lewis Acid theory, as well as acid ionisation reactions. Lewis theory makes a lot of generally non acidic things technically acidic: https://chemed.chem.purdue.edu/genchem/topicreview/bp/ch11/l....
demaga · 3 years ago
I think it's just a pun based on consistency models.
vondur · 3 years ago
As a Chem major it’s cool to see this, but not sure how it ended up on the front page?
chaosjevil · 3 years ago
Ah, Brønsted-Lewis. In defence of the OP:

People informed on Chemistry usually take "acid = you'll get H₃O⁺ in water" and "base = you'll get OH⁻ in water"; that is, the Arrhenius' definition, updated for modern times. Brønsted-Lewis actually makes you think about what's going on (the transference of H⁺), in order to generalise it to other situations.

For example, consider the following reaction:

H₂O + HF ←→ OH⁻ + H₂F⁺

You don't get H₃O⁺ so by Arrhenius' [updated] definition there wouldn't be an acid there. But there is one - H₂O.

And someone might say "but wait, Arrhenius talks about H⁺!" - well, go look for "bare" protons in nuclear fusion, not in chemical reactions.

Eavolution · 3 years ago
Even more interesting is how some chemicals (like water or amino acids) are amphoteric and act as both acids and bases, depending on what environment they are in.
pfdietz · 3 years ago
Gas phase Brønsted acids are kind of mind boggling, if I'm understanding them correctly. They are up to 10^(30) times more acidic than standard strong acids. The goal (I'm not sure if this has been reached) is a compound that in equilibrium has free protons, just bouncing around in space. (In solution, the free protons are always bound to something, for example H3O+ in water.)
zimpenfish · 3 years ago
Reminds me of one of the childhood book titles that I inexplicably remember even as I forget things from last week - "Acids, Bases and the Chemistry of the Covalent Bond". Which [1] tells me was written by Calvin A. VanderWerf, University of Kansas.

[1] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/ed039p273.2

hgsgm · 3 years ago
This is a random section from a chemistry course?

https://flexbooks.ck12.org/cbook/ck-12-chemistry-flexbook-2....

Would be a more accessible document for the audience.

icepat · 3 years ago
Chemistry student are also prolific pirates, any chemistry text you could want is typically available on the web in a PDF format. My personal favourite, Wade's Organic Chemistry 8th Edition, is easily findable on Google.