Readit News logoReadit News

Dead Comment

growlist commented on Colorized and upscaled footage of a snowball fight filmed in 1896   petapixel.com/2020/10/06/... · Posted by u/giuliomagnifico
tshaddox · 5 years ago
Surely this is only a problem if, for whatever reason, a significant number of people are led to believe that the altered footage is an accurate historical representation when that is not the case. People create media that is not an accurate historical representation all the time: fictional movies, cartoons, etc. and presumably historians aren't upset about that.
growlist · 5 years ago
Worth pointing out that the original media itself is compromised as an accurate historical representation.
growlist commented on Colorized and upscaled footage of a snowball fight filmed in 1896   petapixel.com/2020/10/06/... · Posted by u/giuliomagnifico
ortusdux · 5 years ago
There was a lively post on reddit discussing the ethics of colorizing historic photos a few days ago:

https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/j523qi/whats_...

I found this point interesting:

"The thing about old photos is that everything about the image is part of the information we can learn from it—not just the picture itself and what it's a picture of, but how it was composed, what its medium was, the balance of lights and darks... It's all part of the document. And when you start to alter it, that's creating a new document reflecting a conjunction between the past and the present. "

growlist · 5 years ago
IDK. Personally I think it's silly to romanticise and wax lyrical about what are - when it comes down to it - errors in the data; artefacts of the crudeness of the technology that was available when the material was created. Do we routinely add errors of this type to modern footage? No. Why not? Because they detract from the material.

The material is already hugely compromised as a historical document of the reality on the day the events were captured. Let's not put it on a pedestal. For example, if we remove the effect of hand-cranking on film to make it more watchable, are we destroying or enhancing? I would argue the latter. The hand-cranking adds little of value.

growlist commented on Humans are more closely related than we commonly think   scientificamerican.com/ar... · Posted by u/headalgorithm
growlist · 5 years ago
> Humans left Africa and began dispersing throughout the world at least 120,000 years ago

Haven't recent discoveries undermined this theory?

growlist commented on Why Life Can’t Be Simpler   fs.blog/2020/10/why-life-... · Posted by u/feross
carabiner · 5 years ago
I see this all around me. People are fixated on careers, hobbies (FOMO), spread thin by family obligations and errands. The truth is, happiness does not derive from these things. This "busyness" is an invention. Life is simple, and happiness actually derives from having cats.
growlist · 5 years ago
> happiness actually derives from having cats

Not if you're part of the massive destruction of wildlife wrought by these biodiversity annihilators masquerading as cute pets.

'As an invasive species[1] and superpredator,[2] they do considerable ecological damage.[2] In Australia, hunting by cats helped to drive at least 20 native mammals to extinction,[3] and continues to threaten at least 124 more.[3] Their introduction has caused the extinction of at least 33 endemic species on islands throughout the world.[2] Feral and domestic cats kill billions of birds in the United States every year, where songbird populations continue to decline.[4]'

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cat_predation_on_wildlife

growlist commented on Garbage collection via pneumatic tubes   qz.com/1909600/the-future... · Posted by u/fold_left
klyrs · 5 years ago
It's there until the next big earthquake, anyway. Which would probably be more or less okay with garbage, but terrifying for the combination of gas & electric
growlist · 5 years ago
Some areas are pretty much unaffected by earthquakes, like the UK.
growlist commented on Japan’s lost generation is still jobless and living with their parents   bloomberg.com/features/20... · Posted by u/ucha
tonyedgecombe · 5 years ago
Their use of birth control.
growlist · 5 years ago
Perhaps they are using contraception because there are disincentives, and they are working.
growlist commented on Garbage collection via pneumatic tubes   qz.com/1909600/the-future... · Posted by u/fold_left
growlist · 5 years ago
I think there is vast potential for moving all kinds of activities underground. Upfront cost is huge, but once it's done as long as it's maintained it's there for good.
growlist commented on Japan’s lost generation is still jobless and living with their parents   bloomberg.com/features/20... · Posted by u/ucha
tonyedgecombe · 5 years ago
It won't make much difference, people aren't having children because they don't want them.
growlist · 5 years ago
source?
growlist commented on Japan’s lost generation is still jobless and living with their parents   bloomberg.com/features/20... · Posted by u/ucha
pmlnr · 5 years ago
Japan has the problems now we, Western society will be facing in 20 years. This has been true since the 80s, so it's be nice to learn from it, and not follow it.
growlist · 5 years ago
I don't understand why Western countries are not incentivising people to have children.

u/growlist

KarmaCake day1664May 31, 2018View Original