Readit News logoReadit News
catillac commented on Pokemon GAN   huggingface.co/spaces/aut... · Posted by u/aliabd
flor1s · 4 years ago
That's awesome. If I may ask, the data you operate on are still image-like grids or do you operate on more basic data types (e.g. strings)?

Personally I'm also working on an industrial application, using a CycleGAN-based system to augment real world data (e.g. training a network to "paint" an object so we can apply traditional computer vision techniques such as a HSV filter to locate the object). It's quite promising for this kind of application, albeit hard to fine-tune.

catillac · 4 years ago
This is image based, not text based. It’s very useful for a number of applications!

I think your usecase is extremely promising assuming it results in better quality output than just running a modern object detector. Another usecase I don’t have bandwidth for, but would likely be very marketable, is similar to what you’re saying but to allow the use of traditional algos like sift or surf across modalities.

catillac commented on Pokemon GAN   huggingface.co/spaces/aut... · Posted by u/aliabd
flor1s · 4 years ago
Could you give examples of using GAN in prod? Recently there was a discussion on Twitter about the reduced number of GAN papers in the last few years, and some people mentioned that they did not find adoption in industry.
catillac · 4 years ago
Sure, my team and I created “style transfer” GANs to help people better understand particular data in light of other data (the latter of which is usually easier to understand but not always available in practice). It ended up getting strongly positive feedback from large stakeholders, we secured a large contract to deploy, and deployed / maintain it as a SaaS. I even got a patent for the work! I’m sorry I can’t be too much more specific. But, it’s also partially why I may come across as slightly annoyed with the presentation here — HuggingFace is 100% something with functionality I would have preferred to leverage versus my team needing to handle modeling, training, building, releasing, deploying, SLAs, etc. And I would love to support them. But all the presentations being rudimentary with poor UX makes it difficult for me to use them to convince people of this fact, so it’s harder for me to get buy in from finance than it might otherwise be if HF released polished, well thought out demos.

As an aside. I do not personally feel the future of generative modeling is in generative art or creating new Pokémon or things like that, categories which broadly seem like neat tricks without real world usefulness or at least adoption.

catillac commented on Pokemon GAN   huggingface.co/spaces/aut... · Posted by u/aliabd
adamsmith143 · 4 years ago
I think that's a feature of GANS more than anything else. Most papers are cherry picking results to a pretty extreme degree so that they look visually impressive but here you're seeing raw results.
catillac · 4 years ago
I am super familiar with the generative modeling space, have designed them and deployed to real prod, and I will say you’re right that generative modeling results can be hit or miss. But, I was more referring to the page layout, its unreliability (seemed like the author was live debugging in this thread?), poor UX (seems like people can’t easily figure out the page), etc. rather than anything about the model itself (though tbh I also don’t find Pokémon GAN Number 10,000 compelling as a topic). Fundamentally though you do have to always consider results from the latest papers with some baseline skepticism.
catillac commented on Pokemon GAN   huggingface.co/spaces/aut... · Posted by u/aliabd
minimaxir · 4 years ago
These types of demos are typically intended for quick interactive open-source proof-of-concepts rather than an e2e app.
catillac · 4 years ago
Ah that makes sense. Still, feels clunky and not compelling imo, but I may not be the target audience.
catillac commented on Pokemon GAN   huggingface.co/spaces/aut... · Posted by u/aliabd
catillac · 4 years ago
I am a big fan of hugging face, but whenever these examples come up, they always seem to be half baked and don’t quite work well, and are not compelling. I think it would behoove them to polish these a little more, in my opinion.
catillac commented on Putting Ideas into Words   paulgraham.com/words.html... · Posted by u/prtkgpt
chunkyks · 4 years ago
Every time I see some glorious "this explains git in a single image", it's usually an interesting image for someone who already understands git, yet is entirely, 100%, opaque to someone who doesn't yet know git.

[This comment brought to you by a thread [1] from earlier today]

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30311713

catillac · 4 years ago
I saw this earlier, and while I’ve been using git for many years, I think this graphic made me understand git less. Maybe because most of my usage is committing and resetting things and not doing the more wacky git commands?
catillac commented on Peloton – A call for action [pdf]   blackwellscap.com/wp-cont... · Posted by u/a-bit-of-code
mysterydip · 4 years ago
Does anyone here actually use Peloton equipment? My spouse wants one of the bikes but I'm wary of having a subscription to a company with questionable future longevity.
catillac · 4 years ago
I absolutely love it. Tried it for a few days on vacation because the resort had a few, then started doing it at my work gym, then bought one. I was an athlete in high school and college and now in my 30s I’ve tried all kinds of aerobic fitness equipment over the years. It is the most immersive and exciting piece of fitness equipment I’ve ever used, and singularly the only one that has been able to keep my attention as a real option to train versus going outside and running or cycling. I have also heard very similar stories from colleagues.

I think the people calling it a dumb treadmill or saying it can be replaced by YouTube and a used exercise bike are clueless.

catillac commented on Lon Lat Lon Lat   macwright.com/lonlat/... · Posted by u/dbaupp
gmiller123456 · 4 years ago
Worse, I've seen a lot of code that just uses the variable name "ll" as an array of two numbers and make no attempt to clarify which is which. Saved a whole 4 characters by not making it "latlon". Then you get to guess what units they're in.
catillac · 4 years ago
If it’s a variable there’s a reasonable chance it’s used more than once and thus saves more than four characters.
catillac commented on Career advice nobody gave me: Never ignore a recruiter   alexchesser.medium.com/ca... · Posted by u/alexc05
dev_tty01 · 4 years ago
Assuming it is an active real estate with lots of transactions, yes, the agent is absolutely more motivated to close the deal and move on to another deal than to get the highest commission possible on a particular deal. The situation is similar with recruiters. It is important to understand these motivations to correctly interpret what you are hearing from the agents/realtors.
catillac · 4 years ago
I used to work as a waiter when I was in my first summer out of high school. The calculus was similar there. When it was busy the tables turned as soon as the person got up, so I would often not emphasize dessert. The added $15 on the check from dessert increased my tip a couple dollars, but regular desserts could cause me to lose 1-2 full turns of my section over the course of the evening, so with a four table section of everyone for dessert, I might lose 8 tables total, and if the average tip was $20, I’d lose $160 minus the extra $16 in tip gained from everyone having dessert. Point is, I much preferred quick turns over small per capita increases in per table tips.

In non rush times though where tables didn’t get filled when people left, it made a lot more sense to play up dessert.

catillac commented on Cruise is opening driverless cars to the public in San Francisco   getcruise.com/news/welcom... · Posted by u/d-jones
walrus01 · 4 years ago
Based on this image:

https://images.ctfassets.net/95kuvdv8zn1v/6h1C7lPC79OLOlddEE...

They and their VC backers are clearly betting on the concept that radars + lidar + imaging will be the ultimate successful solution in full self driving cars, as a completely opposite design and engineering philosophy from Tesla attempting to do "full self driving" with camera sensors and categorical rejection of lidar.

It is interesting to me that right now this is sitting on the HN homepage directly adjacent to: "Tesla to recall vehicles that may disobey stop signs (reuters.com)"

catillac · 4 years ago
Can someone explain whether there is a principled reason to not use all the sensors available and choose just cameras?

u/catillac

KarmaCake day718December 23, 2020
About
One of the contestants in the Millennial Fair race. I am a normal cat, trained to race. I have a 25% chance of winning.
View Original