Readit News logoReadit News
VladimirGolovin commented on Ask HN: Do you have any evidence that agentic coding works?    · Posted by u/terabytest
loh · 2 months ago
Just for fun, I built a first person shooter game in UE5 from scratch using agentic coding. I've only spent a couple of months on it in my free time so far, and it isn't complete yet, but it's close enough that I could definitely release an early access version with another month or so of work. The most time consuming tasks have actually been tasks that agentic coding hasn't been able to help out with, like animations and mapping. The game is mostly written in C++ and sometimes the agent makes some bad decisions, but with a bit of extra guidance and being smart about my git commits so that I can revert and try again if necessary, I've always been able to make it work the way I want. I most definitely would not have been able to build this on my own in any reasonable amount of time.

FWIW it seems like it heavily depends on the agent + model you're using. I've had the most success with Claude Code (Sonnet), and only tried Opus 4.5 for more complex things. I've also tried Codex which didn't seem very good by comparison, plus a handful of other local models (Qwen3, GLM, Minimax, etc.) through OpenCode, Roo, and Cline that I'm able to run on my 128 GB M4 Max. The local ones can work for very simple agentic tasks, albeit quite slow.

VladimirGolovin · 2 months ago
Did you encounter any issues related to the fact that Unreal Engine uses a specific / custom flavor of C++?
VladimirGolovin commented on Reflections on AI at the End of 2025   antirez.com/news/157... · Posted by u/danielfalbo
fleebee · 3 months ago
> The fundamental challenge in AI for the next 20 years is avoiding extinction.

That's a weird thing to end on. Surely it's worth more than one sentence if you're serious about it? As it stands, it feels a bit like the fearmongering Big Tech CEOs use to drive up the AI stocks.

If AI is really that powerful and I should care about it, I'd rather hear about it without the scare tactics.

VladimirGolovin · 3 months ago
This has been well discussed before, for example in this book: https://ifanyonebuildsit.com/
VladimirGolovin commented on Nikolai Fyodorov wanted to resurrect the dead to live among the stars   lz.kubicki.org/a-letter-a... · Posted by u/szkosma
api · a year ago
The Russians are a people of fascinating extremes.

On one hand, as this explains, they've taken utopian ideas quite seriously and have always been great innovators in the sciences, the arts, and technology. First orbit, first person in space, designed the Tokamak, could easily have been first on the Moon if things had gone a little different, countless great artists and composers, etc.

On the other hand there seems to be a side of Russia that's cynical and nihilistic. There's a joke I heard once that goes something like "in America you die for freedom, in France you die for your country, in England you die for the Queen, and in Russia you die." Today you seem to have dominant thinkers in Russia like Aleksandr Dugin who believe only a tiny number of humans are worthy of agency and this is, with a lot of sophistry, romanticized. For a large number of Russians to swallow this implies to me a level of cynicism about the potential of the human condition.

Or maybe it's not a contradiction. Maybe the utopianism and innovativeness is a brave stand against the cynicism and totalitarian cults of misery-for-most.

The USA of course has its contradictions, like being simultaneously progressive and reactionary. It's a nation built on both slavery and liberation.

VladimirGolovin · a year ago
Russian here. Speaking of Dugin, I'm not a fan of his ideas about archaic way of living, and I don't personally know anyone who likes them. I consider him to be a hypocrite who talks the talk but doesn't walk the walk – unlike German Sterligov, who actually lives in a village without modern technology that he founded and built.

However, there's a sad fact about Dugin. He experienced a personal tragedy – his adult daughter was murdered, likely for political reasons. So, while I'm not a supporter of his ideas, I can never judge him for these ideas considering what he went through. Maybe advocating for these ideas is his way of surviving his tragedy.

VladimirGolovin commented on Tubeworms live around deep-sea vents   economist.com/science-and... · Posted by u/thm
pineaux · a year ago
This will inevitably happen. Life is more robust than electronic systems. The electronic systems will be destroyed for their aggression.
VladimirGolovin · a year ago
I wonder, is an electronic system capable of doing anti-entropy work on itself (the way life does) necessarily AGI-complete? It turns out that there are many complex behaviors (like drawing or generating sensible text) that don't require AGI-completeness.

(Stumbled upon the answer while formulating the question – no, being capable of doing anti-entropy self-maintenance work isn't AGI-complete because there's plenty of life that's perfectly capable of that without being generally intelligent.)

VladimirGolovin commented on 52,000-year-old woolly mammoth chromosomes reconstructed from 'jerky-like' skin   abc.net.au/news/science/2... · Posted by u/speckx
lmpdev · 2 years ago
I personally think successfully resurrecting the Thylacine and reintroducing it longterm to Tasmania would be a better aim over all these comments on Mammoth cloning

Advantages: - smaller (but still a macro-sized animal) - multiple surrogate options rather than just African Elephants - the ecosystem would be better with its capstone apex predator back - it only died out so recently that it has footage from zoos

VladimirGolovin · 2 years ago
Unlike the elephant / mammoth pairing, there aren't any marsupials similar to Thylacine (as far as I know). What surrogate options did you have in mind?
VladimirGolovin commented on Ask HN: How has AI changed your learning methods?    · Posted by u/hubraumhugo
VladimirGolovin · 2 years ago
Thanks to ChatGPT, I'm much less hesitant to delve (haha) into unfamiliar topics. "Hi! I'm a beginner programmer. I'm interested in learning Idris but I know next to nothing about dependent types. Could you explain them in a couple of sentences?"

Then, after the answer, I ask follow-up questions. I also try to check the answers against other sources, e.g. docs or Wikipedia in order to spot hallucinations.

VladimirGolovin commented on Helldivers 2 has caused over 20k Steam accounts to be banned   videogamer.com/news/helld... · Posted by u/josephcsible
modeless · 2 years ago
Steam still supports Russia? How do they do payments?
VladimirGolovin · 2 years ago
Steam works in Russia, but it doesn't accept payments. Free and previously owned games can be played, but new ones cannot be bought. The usual way to circumvent this is via gifting from another account that has working a payment method, e.g. a Georgian or Armenian bank card, or simply playing bought games on the new account.
VladimirGolovin commented on Proof of geometric Langlands conjecture so complex almost no one can explain it   newscientist.com/article/... · Posted by u/isaacfrond
VladimirGolovin · 2 years ago
I feel that long, unexplainable, hard-to-comprehend proofs may become commonplace when we get to AIs that are capable of discovering new proofs on their own.
VladimirGolovin commented on Sam and Greg's response to OpenAI Safety researcher claims   twitter.com/gdb/status/17... · Posted by u/amrrs
Terretta · 2 years ago
Text continuation poses "the greatest of dangers"?
VladimirGolovin · 2 years ago
Text continuation doesn't. AGI does.
VladimirGolovin commented on Riven   filfre.net/2024/05/riven/... · Posted by u/doppp
rkachowski · 2 years ago
> Your reaction to Riven when approached in “gamer” mode will depend on whether you think this kind of intensive intellectual challenge is fun or not, as well as whether you have the excess intellectual and temporal bandwidth in your current life to go all-in on such a major undertaking.

There's a period of time between the nineties and mid 2000s when ubiquitous and fast internet access wasn't easily accessible, and so games like Myst and Riven had the space and time to be digested and savoured. Now it seems this just isn't feasible anymore. There are of course games in the same category, e.g. Outer Wilds and The Witness, but these have much more concessions to the internet age

VladimirGolovin · 2 years ago
To me, both Outer Wilds and The Witness were absolutlely savourable, and I made a point of never looking up anything on the Internet while playing these games. That would rob me of the feelings these games were designed to impart.

u/VladimirGolovin

KarmaCake day779July 16, 2009View Original