Readit News logoReadit News
Lanzaa commented on Starcloud   ycombinator.com/companies... · Posted by u/wiley1454
godelski · 7 months ago
This is exactly right, and an important fact is that there is a limited bandwidth for heat radiation. So essentially they need to create a giant lightbulb...

  > Additionally, deep space is cold, which is accurate in that the "effective" ambient temperature is around -270°C, corresponding to the temperature of the cosmic microwave background.
There's a lot of bad information in their document too. This -270C temperature is ambient space, i.e. deep space. You may experience this when you're in the shadow of Earth or on the dark side of the moon but you're going to switch that negative sign to a positive when you're facing the sun... Which is clearly something they want to do considering that they are talking about solar power. Which means they have to deal with HEATING as well! I don't see any information about this in the document.

  > he mass of radiation shielding scales linearly with the container surface area, whereas the compute per container scales with the volume
This is also a weird statement designed to be deceptive. Your radiation shielding is a shell enclosing some volume.

  > Therefore the mass of shielding needed per compute unit decreases linearly with container size.
They clearly do not understand the mass volume relationship here. Density (ρ) is mass (m) divided by volume (V).

m = ρV.

Let's simplify and assume we're using a sphere since this is the most efficient, giving V = 4/3r^3. Your shield is going to be approximately constant density since you need to shield from all directions (can optimize by using other things in your system).

m ∝ ρr^3

I'm not sure what here is decreasing nor what is a linear relationship. To adjust this to a shell you just need to consider the thickness so you can do Δr = r_outer - r_inner and that doesn't take away the cubic relationship.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_radiation#Characterist...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation

https://www.nasa.gov/smallsat-institute/sst-soa/thermal-cont...

https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/16-851-satellite-engineering-fal...

Lanzaa · 7 months ago
FWIW, i think their description for the radiation shielding is fine. Your analysis is off. If we assume the spherical case, the mass of the shielding is proportional to surface area, not the volume[0]. You might be confusing general radiation shielding and thermal shielding. Thermal shielding is easier because you can point things towards the sun, earth, and moon.

I am more concerned about heat dissipation, which should scale with surface area, but heat generation scales with compute volume.

[0]:

shell thickness, t

compute radius, r

shell volume is (r+t)^3 - r^3 = 3 r^2 t + 3 r t^2 + t^3 = O(r^2)

shielding/compute is O(r^2)/O(r^3) = O(1/r), ie their linear decrease

Lanzaa commented on Starcloud   ycombinator.com/companies... · Posted by u/wiley1454
hatthew · 7 months ago
Followup question, wouldn't nearly any cooling solution that works in space also work on the ground? Radiative cooling is the most basic/common cooling solution on the ground, the main challenge is just figuring out how to to move heat from the component to the radiator, which I don't think is solved by simply putting it in space?
Lanzaa · 7 months ago
I think other have already corrected you, but radiative cooling is probably the least common on the ground and the only viable option in space.

I can help explain why. On earth, we are surrounded by stuff. Radiative cooling relies on thermal radiation leaving an object. Crucially, it also requires the object to absorb less thermal radiation than it emits. On earth we are surrounded by stuff, including air, that emits thermal radiation. There is a window of wavelengths, called the atmospheric window[0], that will allow parts of the thermal radiation out into space, rather than returned back. Imagine shining a flashlight on tinted glass, the light will get through depending on the color. If the light gets through, it has escaped. If not, the light is returned and heats up your surroundings again.

Also on earth the other methods (conduction, convection, and phase changes) are more effective. The earth can be used as a very big heat sink. On a spaceship or satellite, you don't have the extra mass to store the energy, so radiative is the only option.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_window

Lanzaa commented on Starcloud   ycombinator.com/companies... · Posted by u/wiley1454
thekoma · 7 months ago
How does “passive cooling” work in space?
Lanzaa · 7 months ago
Passive cooling refers to "passive radiative cooling"[0]. This is a well established technique, but I have doubts on how well it will scale with the heat generated by computation.

Radiative cooling works by exploiting the fact that hot objects emit electromagnetic radiation (glow), and hot means everything above absolute zero. The glow carries away energy which cools down the object. One complication is that each glowy object is also going to be absorbing glow from other objects. While the sun, earth, and moon all emit large amounts of glow (again, heat radiation), empty space is around 2.7 Kelvin, which is very cold and has little glow. So the radiative coolers typically need to have line of sight to empty space, which allows them to emit more energy than they absorb.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiative_cooling

Lanzaa commented on I decided to pay off a school’s lunch debt   huffpost.com/entry/utah-s... · Posted by u/dredmorbius
chasd00 · 7 months ago
funny thing, i actually thought about that sentence a lot. I added it in after writing the rest of the post because i felt bad implying I subject my kids to school food. I wasn't intending that as a "flex" but just that the food is really bad. On the other hand, i understand not all families have that option so maybe it is a flex in an unintended way.
Lanzaa · 7 months ago
You may not have intended it as a "flex", but you are teaching your children to be snooty. If they have "never" eaten a school lunch, they have judged the lunches based on appearance rather than substance/flavor. I wonder how you have judged the school lunches to be lesser than MREs, perhaps you tried the lunches before your children.
Lanzaa commented on Ask HN: What are you working on? (March 2025)    · Posted by u/david927
iamnnk · 8 months ago
Want to build a platform to alleviate chronic suffering that can't be understood by one's local doctor.

Suggestions by this platform wouldn't interfere with treatment protocol straight away; it wouldn't ask the patient to stop medicines their doctor has prescribed, or itself prescribe scheduled drugs.

It will suggest complementary interventions. Case in point: anxiety, depression, brain degeneration & other related diseases - there's Rhonda Patrick's protocol of HIIT exercises to breach the blood-brain barrier & deliver positive effects; there's Dr Chris Palmer's method of looking at metabolism & mental health jointly & benefits of a keto diet to solve such issues.

Likewise, there can suggestions from Yoga-Pranayama where deep breathing can solve insomnia & hence other diseases downstream such as hypertension in many cases.

After being on such complementary protocols, the patient's suffering will be reduced, but also the body will heal enough to an extent that their local doctor could reduce/stop medication.

The tech is in the platform, combing through wisdom of all such complementary protocols for a start. If it gains traction, we could start involving experts have system route some queries specifically to them.

I have experience building the ML-LLM part. Anyone wants to join me and build the full stack part?

Lanzaa · 8 months ago
You should consider adding contact info to your profile.
Lanzaa commented on I tasted Honda’s spicy rodent-repelling tape and I will do it again (2021)   haterade.substack.com/p/i... · Posted by u/voxadam
wsh · 10 months ago
The manufacturer’s product page, with a link to the MSDS:

https://www.teraokatape.co.jp/english/products/class/class00...

Data sheet describing the “rat prevention effect”:

https://www.teraokatape.co.jp/english/products/Rat_Preventio...

Lanzaa · 10 months ago
Those links are dead.

Correct link to "Rodent-proof vinyl adhesive tape No. 347":

https://www.teraokatape.co.jp/english/products/rodent-proof-...

Lanzaa commented on Show HN: Transductive regular expressions for text editing   github.com/c0stya/trre... · Posted by u/c0nstantine
Lanzaa · 10 months ago
If you are looking for an alternative to standard regex, especially if you have trouble with group logic and are looking for something maintainable, you might like the Rosie Pattern Language.

https://gitlab.com/rosie-pattern-language/rosie/-/blob/maste...

https://rosie-lang.org/about/

Lanzaa commented on Nobody cares   grantslatton.com/nobody-c... · Posted by u/fzliu
parpfish · a year ago
in situations like that, i like to think about Berkson's paradox [0].

In the overall population, bedside manner and medical aptitude are likely uncorrelated. But the individuals that fall into the quadrant of bad bedside manner AND low medical aptitude will be filtered out of the profession. That means that in the remaining population, you have an externally-induced negative correlation between bedside manner and medical aptitude.

So if you find a doctor with bad bedside manner, they're likely to have better medical aptitude otherwise they would've been filtered out.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkson%27s_paradox

Lanzaa · a year ago
I think this application of Berkson's paradox is misleading. A physician can be expected to have a high medical aptitude because of training, not filtering. Medical degrees are not withheld from people with low medical aptitude and given to people with high medical aptitude, people are trained then filtered.

> So if you find a doctor with bad bedside manner, they're likely to have better medical aptitude otherwise they would've been filtered out.

I propose the opposite, a doctor with bad bedside manner likely has lower medical aptitude. I believe there is training for doctors to improve their bedside manner. Then "trainability" may be a latent factor which correlates the quality of a doctor's bedside manner and medical aptitude.

Lanzaa commented on Amazon S3 Adds Put-If-Match (Compare-and-Swap)   aws.amazon.com/about-aws/... · Posted by u/Sirupsen
ndjdjddjsjj · a year ago
It is a shame that comment is not a blog post!
Lanzaa · a year ago
You will like the Strange Loop 2017 talk about this subject:

"Stop Rate Limiting! Capacity Management Done Right" by Jon Moore https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m64SWl9bfvk

Concurrent capacity might not be the best metric.

Lanzaa commented on The meme-ification of the “Demon Core”   doomsdaymachines.net/p/th... · Posted by u/SaberTail
lapetitejort · a year ago
I would like to learn the skill to dodge harmful prolonged sound waves. A technique similar to the safety squint, but with your ears?
Lanzaa · a year ago
The equivalent of safety squints for your hearing would be conscious control of the tensor tympanic muscle. As with safety squints, I don't think there has been much study on the effectiveness.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tensor_tympani_muscle

u/Lanzaa

KarmaCake day102April 25, 2010
About
If you want to email me I have a gmail account with the same username as my HN username.
View Original