Readit News logoReadit News
Hasu commented on Ask HN: Why do we celebrate AI-Copilots but reject AI–Generated art?    · Posted by u/praveeninpublic
tomhow · 4 months ago
All these guidelines are relevant:

Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes.

Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.

It should be clear that this kind of conduct is not acceptable. We're not banning you, we just need you, like everyone, to keep to the guidelines.

Hasu · 4 months ago
I think you are poor moderator acting in bad faith, if you think I violated all those guidelines.

Is that a personal attack? Is that against the guidelines?

I'm not interested in being a part of a community that finds my previous post objectionable. What I said was true and needed to be said. It wasn't kind, but the OP did not deserve or need kindness, he needs a reality check.

> It should be clear that this kind of conduct is not acceptable

It isn't.

Hasu commented on Ask HN: Why do we celebrate AI-Copilots but reject AI–Generated art?    · Posted by u/praveeninpublic
tomhow · 4 months ago
> You are a massive hypocrite, and it seems like you're a scammer and a thief, too.

Personal attacks like this are not OK on Hacker News and we ban people who do it repeatedly.

Please have a read of the guidelines and make an effort to adhere to them in future.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Hasu · 4 months ago
I've considered this, and I don't agree with you. This was not a personal attack (the guidelines you posted also don't forbid personal attacks, they discourage name-calling).

Not my site, so please ban my account.

Dead Comment

Hasu commented on The hidden cost of AI coding   terriblesoftware.org/2025... · Posted by u/Sharpie4679
scarface_74 · 4 months ago
Why should I have a junior developer who is going to do negative work instead of poaching a mid developer who is probably underpaid since salary compression and inversion are real?

As a manager, say I do hire a junior developer, invest time into them and they level up. I go to the HR department and tell them that they deserve a 30% raise to bring them inline with the other mid level developers.

The HR department is going to say that’s out of policy and then the developer jumps ship.

Hasu · 4 months ago
> The HR department is going to say that’s out of policy and then the developer jumps ship.

If you work for a company like this, you should jump ship.

Hasu commented on Mark Zuckerberg says social media is over   newyorker.com/culture/inf... · Posted by u/FinnLobsien
karaterobot · 4 months ago
> With this approach, everybody wants fentanyl.

One difference that may possibly affect the strength of your argument is that fentanyl is a physically addictive drug. Social media may be "addictive" but they aren't addictive. If you genuinely believe they're equivalent, use social media for a year, and fentanyl for a year, and see which is easier to quit.

Actually, scratch that: make it a thought experiment. But if you can see that they aren't equivalent, you can see that it's not a good comparison.

Hasu · 4 months ago
As someone who has struggled with physical and mental addictions for my entire life: breaking a physical addiction is trivially easy compared to breaking a mental addiction. And breaking a physical addiction is really hard (I'm currently suffering withdrawal effects from a recent decision to quit vaping nicotine and it sucks).

Mileage varies for different people, of course. But dopamine is dopamine and addiction is addiction and it's neither kind nor fair to tell someone else that their addiction isn't real because there's no change in their blood chemistry.

Hasu commented on Mark Zuckerberg says social media is over   newyorker.com/culture/inf... · Posted by u/FinnLobsien
grandempire · 4 months ago
You’re right - but the example stands. The CEO is a professional advisor hired to make the rich people money.
Hasu · 4 months ago
This makes no sense in Zuckerberg's case: he was never hired by the board and they've never had a chance to fire him. Investors can sell the stock if they don't like what he does, but that is not a "professional advisor" relationship.

It's mostly a cult of personality relationship, and you're deep in it with your belief that Zuckerberg is an unusually capable operator.

Hasu commented on OpenAI wants to buy Chrome and make it an "AI-first" experience   arstechnica.com/ai/2025/0... · Posted by u/pseudolus
iambateman · 4 months ago
I think the divide between HN and the world is significant, here.

For you (and me), switching browsers is annoying but doable. There was a time when I used Firefox, and then a time when I used Chrome, and someday I'll use something else. But for the vast majority of the world, the idea of switching browsers feels like a big challenge.

A lot of the world needs Chrome to keep working well for them.

Hasu · 4 months ago
> For you (and me), switching browsers is annoying but doable. There was a time when I used Firefox, and then a time when I used Chrome, and someday I'll use something else. But for the vast majority of the world, the idea of switching browsers feels like a big challenge.

Given this paragraph suggests you haven't changed browsers in over 15 years, you should probably give it a try sometime and see if what you think is true still is true.

(If you don't want to do your homework, it is not true. A not-very-technical person could change browsers three times between now and dinner and have no issues)

Hasu commented on Jagged AGI: o3, Gemini 2.5, and everything after   oneusefulthing.org/p/on-j... · Posted by u/ctoth
sandspar · 4 months ago
Forums shed and gain members over time. Much of that cohort is gone.
Hasu · 4 months ago
If anything it's been replaced with a far more naive and gullible cohort, not a more skeptical one.
Hasu commented on Google is illegally monopolizing online advertising tech, judge rules   nytimes.com/2025/04/17/te... · Posted by u/IdealeZahlen
carlosjobim · 4 months ago
If you made your business become completely dependent on a third party, you were already a failure and shouldn't have a business. Being a successful businessman is not a right. It's competition.
Hasu · 4 months ago
I love it when my counterparty's breach of contract is my fault because I foolishly trusted that they would do what they said they would in exchange for my money.

I'm sure you also believe that she was asking for it because she was wearing a short skirt and your dad was right to hit you because you wouldn't shut up.

Hasu commented on How University Students Use Claude   anthropic.com/news/anthro... · Posted by u/pseudolus
bko · 5 months ago
Maybe 40 years ago there were programmers that would not work with anyone that use IDEs or automated memory management. When presented with a programming task that requires these things and you're WITHOUT your IDE or whatever, they will fall apart.

Look, I agree with you, I'm just trying to articulate to someone why they should learn X if they believe an LLM could help them and "an LLM won't always be around" isn't a good argument, because lets be honest, it likely will. This is the same thing as "you won't walk around all day with a calculator in your pocket so you need to learn math"

Hasu · 5 months ago
> This is the same thing as "you won't walk around all day with a calculator in your pocket so you need to learn math"

People who can't do simple addition and multiplication without a calculator (12*30 or 23 + 49) are absolutely at a disadvantage in many circumstances in real life and I don't see how you could think this isn't true. You can't work as a cashier without this skill. You can't play board games. You can't calculate tips or figure out how much you're about to spend at the grocery store. You could pull out your phone and use a calculator in all these situations, but people don't.

u/Hasu

KarmaCake day1096September 16, 2013View Original