Readit News logoReadit News
41209 commented on Godot for AA/AAA game development – What's missing?   godotengine.org/article/w... · Posted by u/milliams
caniszczyk · 3 years ago
If you are looking for a AAA open source engine today with an open community, check out https://www.o3de.org

I hope Godot continues to improve and competition increases in the open source AAA gaming engine space as this space is well overdue for fully open source options.

41209 · 3 years ago
I wouldn't attach myself to it, the community( Amazon employees mostly) are friendly, they'll even offer to help you with any issues you run into.

But seriously, no games exist, no real demo projects with it exist. For some reason it uses Lua instead of strongly typed language like C#.

Seriously, games NEED types. At scale projects get really messy without them. Oh wait, O3de pushes script canvas on you.

At the end of the day , I find myself getting sucked back into Unity. Unity could be better, but it's still the best engine for most people. Much of that is just due to documentation. For some reason Amazon decided effectively hide all of it's old Lumberyard docs and examples when they rebranded as O3de. No one will ever know why.

41209 commented on Show HN: AI-powered code correction that teaches you along the way   useadrenaline.com... · Posted by u/jshobrook
41209 · 3 years ago
I would love this as a Visual Studio or VS Code plugin.

Using it as a standalone website looks fun too, can't wait to dig into this !

41209 commented on Launch HN: MagnaPlay (YC W23) – Indie gaming subscription service for PC    · Posted by u/Pedro_Magna
41209 · 3 years ago
I really like the idea, but Humble Bundle Choice does this much much better and has been around for well over a decade. With Humble I get Steam keys and I don't have to install another client.

I honestly don't see how this business model can work, the competition is really really good at what it does. I have Gamepass and Humble which frankly gives me more than I can even play.

Now what could work would be a publisher offering whatever games it sells for a monthly fee. As in, you get the September game( maybe it's 6 months old at this point) and get to keep it even after canceling. Then again, Humble publishes a ton of games, so their already doing this.

41209 commented on Ask HN: Why is UI design in Unity so hard?    · Posted by u/41209
redefine_net · 4 years ago
I'm glad I'm not alone with my frustrations over Unity. I feel like Unreal is clumsy as well for new developers, so it's a choice between which shortcomings you prefer. Can't wait for a new engine to fill in the gap.
41209 · 4 years ago
Honestly this post is like complaining my new car only has manual windows.

Everything else with Unity is pretty easy. I hate Blueprints or any visual scripting. In the long term Blueprints don't build any real skills, and I learned to program with Unity.

41209 commented on Ask HN: Why is UI design in Unity so hard?    · Posted by u/41209
terrycody · 4 years ago
Try godot instead.
41209 · 4 years ago
Godot has potential, but it’s no where near Unity in terms of ease of use.

With Unity I can typically buy an asset for whatever I need, but with Godot I might need to implement it myself. Unity has tons of problems, but better off with the devil you know

41209 commented on Ask HN: Why is UI design in Unity so hard?    · Posted by u/41209
oneoff786 · 4 years ago
I have found unreal’s basic ui editor to be fine.

Unity is, in my opinion, just a poorly managed company with a good product in spite of it. They’ve failed to deliver on many things and the engine has glaring weaknesses, e.g. no networked multiplayer built in. I would bet on the engine generally getting worse over time as management tries to push non functioning new stuff.

41209 · 4 years ago
I vastly prefer code over blueprints, and C# is much easier than C++.

I've tried learning Unreal like 3 times. I still can't even get the build chain working

41209 commented on Major milestone ready for testing: Godot 4.0 alpha 1 is out   godotengine.org/article/d... · Posted by u/41209
daypay · 4 years ago
Glad to see this release. Looking forward to making some pull requests on bugs. Can’t wait for the first beta. Huge kudos to the team and all contributors.
41209 · 4 years ago
Same, I'm a Unity dev but we desperately need a FOSS option.

How is the inspector/menu system compared to Unity.

u/41209

KarmaCake day543June 4, 2021View Original