Readit News logoReadit News
narrator · 4 years ago
I downloaded it and tried it and I'm not super interested in it. I've tried a number of different task/to do tools over time. What's working for me now is the following Google Doc that works as follows. If today is 4/10/22:

4/10/22

>Write Article

>Go Shopping

* Milk

* Cereal

>Pay Plumber

If I only paid the plumber that day and bought cereal, on the next day you'd have:

4/10/22

>Pay Plumber

>Go Shopping

* Cereal

4/11/22

>Write Article

>Go Shopping

* Milk

That's basically the whole thing. Of course there's a standard calendar app too. After a few months it gets long and you roll over into a new doc. I can always scroll to the bottom and I have a nice diary of things I accomplished. I don't know how you could improve the implementation over a google doc. The good thing about a Google Doc is if I get stuck on some todo I can brainstorm right in the doc. That's the hardest part with a to do system. Some To Dos stay on there for a while and need a lot of context, creativity and brainstorming to get done.

Kunix · 4 years ago
Done the same for over 10 years with a local "@Worklog.md" file on a light text editor (to get syntax highlighting). Can be synced with Dropbox or Obsidian too.

Recently switched to do the same on Notion, moving items in a "Worklogs" database at the end of each month (with one entry per month) to keep the Worklog size manageable. If a task gets too long I can just create a sub-page for it (or a toggle), put all the context information there, and just add a link to the TODO item.

codemac · 4 years ago
Mark Forster has a great version of this, lovingly called "the final version": https://archive.ph/Gts2v
1ste · 4 years ago
For me, adding items/tasks to time bound columns/lists does not work for me. Sometimes I have inspiration to clear my list and sometimes I do not.

I made https://easylists.app to solve my own problem. I want to make lists fast and essentially to treat them as throw away (just like pen and paper). Sometimes I have a "today" list. Sometimes I have a "Top 3" list. I change it up all the time.

garrett_makes · 4 years ago
Not exactly the same but similarly I made https://quicktodos.com for my wife and I to quickly share lists with real-time updating for things like going to the store or a daily task list.

Funny how so many of these exist with slightly different takes on the problem!

jjnoakes · 4 years ago
Just some random feedback - I like the look and feel, but if I type quick enough, the order of my keystrokes doesn't match the order of operations.

For example, if I focus an empty text field to start entering list items, and I type this quickly: "1 (Enter) 2 (Enter) 3 (Enter)" I get something like "1" as the first item, "23" as the second item, and two empty items below, as if I had typed "1 (Enter) 2 3 (Enter) (Enter)".

rockzom · 4 years ago
Nice work. This isn't your fault, but it's inspiring a tangent.

It's so strange, but I hate being so spoiled for choice.

The main thing I miss about software from 20 years ago is that there were rarely more than two or three answers to the "which software should I use?" question. By today's standards, the tools we had were subpar. But it was easier to tell the best of the "worst" from the worst of the best.

I recall it being more of an issue with file size, stability, and RAM usage. The question of "does this have everything I need?" didn't often occur to us, because that seemed like a ludicrous proposition in a "hey, this thing is less than a meg to download!" environment.

These days, without a substantial amount of (sometimes dubious at best) preliminary research, you don't get to find out if something meets your needs until you have invested enough time to feel somewhat trapped in the new ecosystem.

Ultimately, I'm not saying things used to be better. The tools we have now are miraculous. It's just for those of us who got to experience web search before Google and web search after Google...we will always be searching for that next hit of finding a tool that is so dramatically and obviously better than its predecessors.

gregmac · 4 years ago
While I agree part of that was being that there were fewer options, there's also just more complexity these days.

I consider things like:

* Does this synchronize to other devices?

* Does this support the device(s)/OS(es) I want to use it on?

* Does this integrate to other applications I use?

* Is this likely to contain malware, or could it in the future?

* Does it require me running my own infrastructure, or can I pay someone else?

* Am I comfortable with the extent I'll be locked into this ecosystem, if any?

* Is it a worthwhile cost to me? Is the price likely to radically change in the future (after I'm locked in)?

* If free, why? (Am I the product? Are there or will there be ads?)

* If open source, is it likely to stay that way? Is there a community around it? Am I capable of maintaining this if I need to?

* What new security threats does this open me up to?

Granted, I don't always care about all of these (sometimes depending on answers to others), but it's a way bigger list than I'd have had 20 years ago.

umangrathi · 4 years ago
Thank you, its a great check list
wjdp · 4 years ago
Just installed it to play around. Really nice to have a purely offline app in this space.

What did surprise me is the unskippable 'splash screen' with the sponsor message before the app is usable (several seconds), this would really annoy me if there's no way to get rid of it.

raidel94 · 4 years ago
I really like the app. To be honest the sponsor message didn't bother me that much, but it's real that it's there for several seconds. Is it intentional or is it loading the app?
s3p · 4 years ago
I've never seen an app take that long to launch on my machine before, so I think this is to highlight the sponsor.
klabb3 · 4 years ago
What application bundler is this using? Assuming electron, but the github repo only contains assets and translation so it's hard to tell.
raidel94 · 4 years ago
I was looking at the repository and in the tags it says electron.
s3p · 4 years ago
yikes. so there's no reason to download it lol, we get the same experience as running it in-browser
sgt · 4 years ago
Exactly what I wanted to know. There's no way I want to run another heavy weight Electron app.
ale42 · 4 years ago
same here!
tillcarlos · 4 years ago
I like the concept. I plan my week in a similar manner with Notion: just add headlines for every week day.

My issue is that the tasks often overflow and I rarely clean them up consistently.

How does this app solve the problem of overwhelm?

ildon · 4 years ago
You should try Akiflow.com! there's an awesome notion integration that makes it really efficient to plan notion pages
butwhywhyoh · 4 years ago
It's a minimalist planner app. Why would it solve (self-inflicted) problems for you?
s3p · 4 years ago
well planner apps aren't designed to MAKE problems now are they?
jeffkeen · 4 years ago
I hate to be that guy, but this looks exactly like https://teuxdeux.com/, a service made by Tina Roth Eisenberg (https://www.swiss-miss.com/) which has been around for a long long time.

More than one product can exist in a space (and todo lists are a dime a dozen) and maybe this was a completely original idea and GMTA, but wow it sure looks like a note for note copy

weego · 4 years ago
And both look exactly like the A4 tear-out paper planners my partner has used for years. They're both digital iterations of a well trodden path
jstummbillig · 4 years ago
It's a very simple weekly planer. There is going to be columns with weekdays and in those list items. There are a lot more than these two apps in this space. I personally enjoy https://tweek.so/

The privacy and locally hosted angle seems like plenty of differentiation.

Other than that I'd have to squint very, very hard to make it look "exactly" like TeuxDeux (which I find a lot less appealing, visually)

wjdp · 4 years ago
Another user of tweek here, loving the competition in the space though! The fact this can run offline without an account is great.
2143 · 4 years ago
Yes. TeuxDeux.

I knew this app looks exactly like something else I've seen before, but I couldn't recall the name.

However, I don't consider this to be a copy of TeuxDeux because there's nothing particularly revolutionary in either app's design — they're both just digital versions of paper planners.

As far as todo apps go, I've tried them all. The problem I have with most of them is that they don't separate deadline with do-time. I want to plan a task such that deadline might be on Friday, but I intend to actually do the thing on Tuesday. Apps don't allow me to record that information.

When I first heard about TeuxDeux about an year ago I realized that the old fashioned and obvious weekly planner strategy could work. Since TeuxDeux wasn't free (I could be wrong because I now see a free version in their website), I just used a Google Doc to write down what I intended to do every day of the week.

And it worked reasonably well.

I'm happy to see WeekToDo come out. And it's open source!

marban · 4 years ago
IIRC Julius Caesar's or the Egyptian's take on the calendar have been around longer than Swissmiss' app.
shaolinspirit · 4 years ago
I swear, teuxdeux is the most laconic and functional planner I've ever tried and it looks stunning. I'm so happy I found this comment, thanks @jeffkeen
jimmydddd · 4 years ago
A benefit of teuxdeux is that they charge $2 a month with the intention of putting the funds to maintaining the site and not having to sell the company.
gramie · 4 years ago
$3/month. Maybe it changed recently?

Edit: we're kind of both right. $3/month, or $24/year.

thex10 · 4 years ago
I came here to say the same thing!

Frankly it’s a great concept and I might use it myself.

Deleted Comment

Dicey84 · 4 years ago
Generally like how simple the app is, but as an Aussie, I find starting the week on a Sunday off-putting.
pcurve · 4 years ago
When I open the web version of the calendar picker, it's showing Monday as the irst day of the week?

Btw, I didn't realize vast majority of the world outside Americas have week starting on Monday.

brewdad · 4 years ago
I've switched my calendar to start on Monday (as a USAian) because I prefer to not have my weekends split across two different rows. This became especially important as my kid's activities would fill our weekend and needing to ensure nothing else of importance was missed in planning out our upcoming week(s).